Obama vs Romney
by Andrew Plygawko
The home stretch is approaching. On November 6th the American people will go to the polls to elect their next president. It is a decision that will have ramifications beyond four years of policy and law-making. It will set the direction of the United States in terms of ideology, in terms of its role on the world stage and, less overtly, in terms of electoral practice.
A decisive win on the themes of hope and change in 2008 cemented Barack Obama’s place as an international champion; a revolutionary candidate who could strip away the intrigue from politics and halt the slide into economic depression.
Four years on, many Americans feel differently. His approval ratings have been middling, rarely hitting 50% in the past two years. For over three years the `right track/wrong track’ poll has been damning, with the vast majority of Americans believing Obama to be leading his country down the wrong path. Even his signature `Obamacare’ bill, which has provided millions more with healthcare, has proven at best divisive, at worst unpopular. The contrast between 2008 and 2012 seems stark. So what happened?
On the simplest level, the major thorn in President Obama’s side has been the economy. The Democrats inherited a disastrous situation from the Bush administration; from early 2008 to mid-2009, under Republican economic policy, 7.5 million jobs were lost. Whilst Obama’s policies have been largely successful in tackling these ill fortunes, providing two years of job creation and 4.6 million new jobs since March 2010, many Americans feel it hasn’t been enough.
Unemployment is mired at over 8% and the latest reports show jobs growth slowing and manufacturing levels falling. The United States is definitely on the road to prosperity, but for the jobless it is a long road to walk. Obama’s stimulus package may have saved jobs, improved quality of life for many, and helped to stem a possible tide of homelessness by subsidising mortgages, but this isn’t seen as a strong enough case for re-election.
This is Obama’s second problem. Expectations were set so high when he took office that no matter how well he did putting the country back on the road to recovery, it would never have been enough in the eyes of the American people. Even in perfect economic conditions he would have struggled to live up to the expectation he created. For all the good he has done in his first term it has been overshadowed by past notions of sweeping change.
With this bleak outlook for Obama in mind, the Republicans should have had a relatively easy task ahead of them. Why, then, are they left scratching their heads at the president’s persistent lead in the polls over their own nominee Mitt Romney?
There are several possible explanations. Firstly, the race has matured into more than a mere referendum on Obama’s handling of the economic crisis. The recent eruption of anti-Western riots across the Middle East has catapulted foreign policy into the campaign, placing Romney on the back foot.
An incumbent president will usually have the upper hand in a foreign policy debate due to their experience with international relations. Obama is also likely to receive a poll boost, albeit temporarily, due to the `Rally Round the Flag’ effect. The American people picture the president as a symbol of national unity and support them accordingly during times of diplomatic crisis.
Beyond that, an opposition party cannot resolve foreign policy issues themselves and so cannot take any credit. Meanwhile criticism of the government’s handling of the situation backfires amidst claims of politicising national tragedies, as Romney has so recently learned. Pair this with Romney’s infamous criticism of the London Olympics and Putin’s recent remarks that he would prefer to work with an Obama administration, and the incumbent becomes the more credible figure to represent America on the global stage.
The same can be said of healthcare. By choosing Paul Ryan as his running mate, Romney evoked a barrage of harsh criticisms; Ryan championed a controversial budget that proposed scrapping current medical care for the elderly and replacing it with private insurance schemes partially subsidised by the government.
Such a risky Vice Presidential pick proved a double-edged sword. Ryan, a devout Catholic, helped to assuage any doubts amongst grassroots Republican voters regarding Romney’s Mormon faith, and choosing the author of a budget strengthened the appeal of the Republican party amongst voters longing for a better economy.
On the other hand, his arrival on the national scene magnified scrutiny of the Ryan Plan, exposing several flaws with the arithmetic that comparatively strengthened Obama on the economy. Beyond that, the budget proved widely unpopular with the elderly who were afraid of losing their healthcare entitlements. The elder demographic will prove very important in swing states such as Florida, and losing their vote could prove fatal for the Republicans.
But even the widening campaign perspective only explains Romney’s recent flagging in the national polls. The only long-term explanation for the resilience of the polls is very simple. People have, in general, already made up their minds. Very few undecided voters still exist, with the unprecedented number of campaign adverts leading many to reach their final conclusions long before the Election Day.
Many independents are supporting Obama’s re-election campaign as Romney is widely seen as less trustworthy due to his oft-mentioned founding of the investment colossus Bain Capital, and is depicted as caring little for the middle class. These concerns were only further validated by the secret tapes leaked of a fundraising speech in which he stated his job was “not to worry about those people” who rely on government welfare.
This helps us understand why the race has for so long been so close, and why nothing seems to change that significantly. It also explains Romney’s ideological shift towards the right on social issues in recent months. Setting a narrative of economic restoration and playing to independent voters’ concerns over Obama’s recovery plans has not done enough to guarantee him a shot at victory. With President Obama holding a narrow yet crucial lead in many swing states, Romney has only one viable tactic left if he wants any chance of taking the Oval Office come November; he must rally the grassroots supporters, pander to the traditional Republican base, and hope for the best.
Photograph: Flickr ID – DonkeyHotey

