Harpal Brar’s socialist standpoint fails to deliver

by Owen Walpole

The presence at this week’s DUS debate of the erudite but highly controversial Harpal Brar was always likely to cause a stir. The Communist Party of Great Britain stalwart, a man famed for the strength of his Marxist-Leninist convictions, did not disappoint.

After Brar had attempted – unsuccessfully as it turned out – to convince the Palace Green audience that capitalism had failed, I was able to meet him face to face and get a better insight into his views. Flanked by his son and comrade in arms, Ranjeet, his passion is obvious but the weight of his dogmatism made for an interview which felt impersonal and distant.

Disillusionment with the political process is rife at the moment and bankers, bail-outs and sub-prime busts have created a lot of anger. Why then have left wing movements struggled to make an impact? For Brar, the answer to this lies in the bourgeois capitalists’ control of the coercive powers of the state, as well as the way in which the Labour Party has colluded with capitalism and betrayed the working classes. If Brar was taking an exam on the communist interpretation of history, he would get – and please excuse the pun – full Marx here.

The academic and political criticisms of his labour theory of value and ‘overproduction’ narrative are one thing, but crucially these ideas just fail to resonate in the public mind. The issues that matter to people such as the NHS and unemployment are what the public wants its political figures to address.

This failure to connect emotionally with public opinion was evident when Brar discussed the current situation in Syria. Despite claims by human rights groups that upwards of 28,000 people have gone missing thanks to what Avaaz called ‘a government regime of terror’ Brar said: “I am fully behind Assad’s regime as it protects freedom in the area and is being attacked by purely imperialist interests.” This is reflective of his attitude towards Stalinist Russia, towards which he is unapologetic in his support.

Whilst I was speaking to Brar, a nearby student questioned whether he had ever read Solzhenitzen’s ‘Gulag Archipelago’ or the accounts of those kept in Stalin’s camps. He was highly dismissive of this point and stressed the flimsy evidence of atrocities built up by CIA agents on Stalin and Mao.

This is a view little shared by the majority of the socialist movements in Britain but it reflects a certain paranoia inherent in Brar’s mindset. It also highlights the extent to which ideas based on overbearing structural theories fail to resonate with people as the correct emotional response to political and social problems.

Furthermore, Brar formed his convictions by reading Marx and Lenin, who for him “just made sense”. The problem is that for the majority, their views do not. The idea that the value of labour is purely a reflection of the time and effort a worker puts in is highly questionable. It takes no account of the value of ideas and the need to offset risk against profit.

The recent handling of the economy may have felt like an abuse of trust, but in a liberal democracy people recognize the importance of innovation, ideas and entrepreneurship in delivering prosperity. Marxism and socialism more generally, it is feared, do not deliver this.

Ultimately then, despite Brar’s conviction that Marx is “making a come back”, I do not believe that British opinion will ever be inclined to seek solace in his ideas. The crisis has highlighted numerous problems within the system and requires a great deal of answers. But as has been shown, people still appeal to the state to regulate excess in the monetary system, provide a check on the inequalities of capitalism and in the end get us out of this mess.

For more information on the Durham Union Society debates, visit their website: www.dus.org.uk

Photograph: Adam Jones on Flickr.