Nothing left to lose

By Henry Fernandez

One sentiment cropping up about the Labour Leadership Contest is that Sir Keir Starmer’s victory is a step back-ward. Some are already bemoaning the victory of the New Labour Forces in taking back the party from Corbyn.

I didn’t take much of an interest in politics until Year 12, when I was too young to vote in the 2015 general election. Naively, I campaigned for the Tories in a school-mock general election, out of a child-like-desire to oppose your parent’s opinions. I became somewhat of a crude Tory stereotype. However, part of the journey that ends in political maturity involves taking a coldly honest look at the past beliefs one has held, even if one is not proud of them now.

During my gap year, I had work colleagues who were extremely disillusioned with the British Political class, portraying it as broken and rigged. Corbyn was seen as the only honest one in that house of self-serving snakes known as Parliament.  

I felt old at the time, but I was still an impressionable child. I drifted over to the other extreme, becoming increasingly bitter and scornful towards May. I became a frequent visitor to The Guardian message boards, which are just as tribal as The Sun’s columnists, and increasingly saw politics in harsh black and white, rather than shades of grey. 

I despaired over how my parents, who were intelligent and university educated, were being hoodwinked by the press-propaganda-machine.

Labour needs to be a governing party, not a protest party

I voted to remain in the 2016 Brexit Referendum, held just after I left school. I initially insisted that it be overturned at all costs, cheering on MPs who undermined May at every turn. This was driven by a desire to see May humiliated, despite initially lauding her careful approach.  

I twice voted for Corbyn. By the time the election of 2019 came around, university had broadened my horizons as it inevitably does. I began to see my close Tory friends as those who also wanted the best for the country and all British Citizens, who merely happened to disagree on the best contingent economic and social means to achieve said shared ends. I became increasingly sceptical of Corbyn, his ‘present-but-not-involved’ comments about the wreath-laying controversy being a turning point. I found it increasingly hard to ignore the barrage of evidence of his odd worldviews. Whilst recognising the undeniable clutches of the Murdoch propaganda machine, I could no longer commit to this fantasy of a Blairrite conspiracy of bankers, politicians and news journals determined to destroy Corbyn’s name.

I gave Corbyn the benefit of the doubt one last time in December 2019 but breathed an inner sigh of relief when Boris Johnson won the majority I saw as inevitable. I see that moment as the turning point of my finally maturing politically.

The problem as I now see it is that Labour needs to be a governing party and not a protest vote. Grown-up government is about precisely that, governing. It is about electability, not occupying some moral high-ground, where one can pat oneself on the back for being a good person who has not sacrificed their principles. Corbyn’s ‘ideological purity’ increasingly begins to look like arrogance and smug self-congratulating the longer one looks at it. 

Think about Rebecca Long-Bailey, touted as Corbyn’s heir. Yes, she may have been ‘ideologically pure’. Yet, look at how this twisted her. Long-Bailey lied about remembering her dad being laid off by Thatcher’s government, as if left-wing politics is some sort of competition to flaunt your ‘gritty’ working-class credentials. RLB would have consigned them to another decade out of office. Her working-class credential games alienated my Grandad, from a council house in Blackburn, who buried his mother’s stillborn second child in a shoebox in a pauper’s grave. If they can’t win him over who can they win over? 

RLB would have consigned them to another decade outside of office

The game Corbynistas continue to play months later, where they still blame anybody but the man himself for his loss, is not only ludicrous and dangerous but,  if I may resort to hyperbole to prove my point, a slippery path that leads to fascists taking decisions in the ‘best interest’ of a deluded electorate who do not know what is in their own good. People still bemoan that all Brexit voters are stupid, racist, old, white and working-class. These attitudes reek of arrogance, elitism and ignorance, a refusal of the Corbyns of the world to engage with real people, as much in their ivory towers as anybody else. 

Corbyn had many flaws, as all politicians do, and must own them. He is not some saint that a true ‘enlightened’ and non-blinded electorate would have fallen head over heels in love with. I recognise the extent of the problematic political-media machinery, but to start talking about who people would have really voted for had their reason been functioning properly etc. is very, very dangerous territory indeed and I hope readers of any and all political colours agree with me on this point. 

I am not denying that Blair and his Labour movement need to face questions over the Iraq debacle. Labour must own their flaws, all parts of Labour. 

However, we have to give Starmer a fighting chance. As a centrist I twice gave Corbyn the benefit of the doubt and my vote. Starmer deserves the same chance from all factions of Labour. It would now be hypocritical if the Party does not give Starmer a fair chance, after they violently ordered all Labour MPs to get behind and support their infallible leader, Corbyn. 

Image: Chris McAndrew via Creative Commons