Northern Ireland: a victory with a sour taste

By Ronan Burke

In the North, we often joked that crossing the border from the Republic of Ireland was like entering a time machine back to the 19th century. Same-sex marriage? Illegal. Abortion? Illegal. Until 2019, our abortion legislation dated from 1861, 60 years before Northern Ireland even existed. This week, momentous changes came as it was announced that six years after being legal in the rest of the UK, and five years after receiving a 53-52 majority in Stormont, Northern Irish same-sex couples are now free to marry.

But what took so long? Well, if you want a glimpse of the 19th century, look at our most popular party, the DUP. Their opposition to same-sex marriage rights is that they “redefine” marriage, with former DUP minister Jim Wells infamously saying “Peter will not marry Paul in Northern Ireland”. Wells made even Piers Morgan look liberal by criticizing the introduction of same-sex dance couples on Strictly on Good Morning Britain. First, they used their veto known as the ‘petition of concern’ to prevent legislation passing, despite it receiving a majority in Stormont. Second, after losing 10 seats in the 2017 Assembly election, thus removing their ability to block such legislation, the DUP played a large part in sustaining a political deadlock that shut Stormont down for three years, only re-opening last Sunday. Same-sex marriage was one of their main ‘red lines’ in negotiation.

Amidst the deadlock, in July 2019, MPs backed amendments which required that same-sex marriage (and abortion) laws be extended to NI if devolution was not restored by October. As this deadline passed and this week’s announcement came, leading campaigner John O’Doherty of “Love Equality”, one of the biggest advocacy groups for LGBT rights in Northern Ireland, said this “marks an enormous step forward for LGBT+ people”.

The fight for human rights in Northern Ireland has just begun

But why does this victory leave a sour taste? The fight for human rights in Northern Ireland has just begun While we have finally achieved equal rights for same-sex couples, this victory feels imposed on us by Westminster, rather than agreed to. It didn’t come about in our Assembly, by our politicians or for the most part, our votes. South of the Border, the Republic has made this and other such progressive changes through referenda, while we rely heavily on those sitting on Westminster benches. A reliance which, many hoped, was a thing of the past.

If Northern Ireland wants to make more truly progressive, meaningful changes, as we celebrate this momentous victory for human rights in the North, we must not stop there. With three of the biggest churches in Northern Ireland explicitly saying they won’t perform same-sex marriage ceremonies, the rights of same-sex couples are still not set in stone.

Image: NICVA via Creative Commons