DUCFS criticism: Bearing the brunt of an under-representative fashion industry

By Ronan Burke

There’s only three things we can be certain of in life: death, taxes and criticism of the Durham University Charity Fashion Show. Each year, people are quick to point out that while DUCFS is an incredible fundraising platform, we must condemn its unrepresentative choice of models.

A recent article in The Tab, for example, criticised the fashion show for perpetuating societal beauty standards which are “unrealistic and potentially unhealthy”, both in terms of body type and ethnicity. Essentially, that DUCFS is full of skinny white girls or buff white guys.

Is this criticism warranted? Well, let’s be clear, the under-representative nature of DUCFS is a problem. In their introduction to the Models of 2020, the Fashion Show website argues that there is “still so much to be done” to “improve the lack of diversity and perpetuation of negative attitudes towards unrealistic body image”.

The organizers thus clearly share the philosophy that Fashion shows must be representative and challenge the unhealthy body standards that persist. So why are they criticized every year for doing the exact opposite?

If the problem lies with recruitment, as is suggested, then one of either two things is happening. First: DUCFS are intentionally looking for the models to portray the typical ‘perfect’ body image presented in the typical Western fashion industry, thus rejecting ‘plus size’ and BME applicants. Second: While DUCFS look to promote representation, the applicants they receive are an unrepresentative sample. That is, those who apply are often not from ‘plus size’ or BME backgrounds, but rather are white and often ‘that’ certain body type.

Even without a log of DUCFS’ applicants’ information, there are various reasons to expect the second scenario. First, the fashion industry is famously a ‘white-washed’ institution, which perpetuates a reluctance of black and minority ethnic people to engage. That is, without having any models to look up to, prospective BME models often feel as if the catwalk isn’t for them. Similarly, the absence of ‘plus-size’ models at London Fashion Week may also put off those interested in modelling.

DUCFS’ lack of representation seems to be a symptom of a wider problem, that those of different body types or ethnicities may not feel welcome in a Fashion Show.

DUCFS’ lack of representation seems to be a symptom of a wider problem, that those of different body types or ethnicities may not feel welcome in a Fashion Show. Looking at the ‘perfect’ body types that the media and fashion industry perpetuate, potential applicants are reluctant to even think about auditioning. Blaming a Charity Fashion show for the endemic unrepresentativeness of the Fashion industry seems to be barking up the wrong tree.

The previously mentioned Tab article rejects this, arguing that “The university setting offers the perfect opportunity to evade the real-world stipulations of the fashion industry”, and that DUCFS should pave a “new way” of fashion show.

So, what can the organizers do? Set a quota based on ethnicity and body type? Approach BME/ ‘plus size’ students in the Library and make it compulsory for them to audition? If these seem absurd, then it’s clear that DUCFS must not be wholly blamed for their unrepresentative choice of models.

To provoke meaningful change in the representativeness of the fashion industry, we must create a culture where BME/ ‘plus size’ people feel as if they can audition, and this starts from the top. This starts from fashion magazines, catwalks and TV shows empowering BME/ ‘plus size’ models, creating role models for young people to look up to. I hope that DUCFS continue their philosophy of challenging the stereotypes given in the fashion industry, and that we can create a culture where everyone feels comfortable on the Rainton Arena catwalk.

Photo: Mark Spagnuolo via Flickr