‘Nocturnal Animals’: style over substance, but does it matter?

By Eloise Pearson

At heart Nocturnal Animals is inherently, irresistibly stylish. After all, what else would we expect from fashion designer turned film director Tom Ford?

Based on the novel 1993 novel Tony and Susan by Austin Wright, Nocturnal Animals presents a sleek, elegant, neo-noir psycho-thriller. An aesthetic triumph from the opening sequence, the movie is a cinematographer’s wet dream.

The film follows gallery owner Susan (Amy Adams) who, while clinging to the remnants of her loveless marriage to swanky businessman Walker (Armie Hammer), receives a dark and violent manuscript from her ex-husband Edward Sheffield (Jake Gyllenhaal). In fitting conjunction with the ultra-modern visuals, the narrative becomes very meta at this point. Susan begins to read the manuscript which becomes the dark heart of the film. Add in on extremely ambiguous ending and several online fan theories and you can score yourself a healthy 73 on Rotten Tomatoes.

Certain critics, however, slam Ford for his ‘style of substance’ technique, an anxiety I was aware of as I walked into the cinema.

To some extent I see how this argument holds up. The inner violence and meta, melodramatic plot within a plot, is indeed muffled somewhat by the slick, snow globe exterior. And yes, Adam’s character does seem to exist primarily to take long showers and walk seductively up staircases. Saying this, I can’t help but feel that this beautiful, glossy exterior exists in a way that is perhaps quite meta itself.

Ford’s film may be style over substance but largely, I think, that is the point. So is Susan’s reality. So is the modernist egg in which she lives her life. In a way, so is a civilisation that watches world crisis after world crisis through the sleek plasma of a television screen.

I thoroughly enjoyed watching ‘Nocturnal Animals’. It was visually stunning and perfectly nihilistic. Do I think it was substantially important or life changing? No. Do I think it had a rich, detailed plot or well-developed characters? The film is meant to be insubstantial and nihilistic. You’re not meant to be able to hold anyone accountable. The ending was unresolved in the best possible way in that Susan’s life is left just as empty as when the film began.  She is sad and attractive, posed like a girl in one of Ford’s own glossy photoshoots.

Nocturnal Animals is not a film I would go watch if you want anything tangible or easy to understand without a cheeky google afterwards. But dizzying, haunting, poised and stunning? This film wins every time. You’ll probably not re-watch it but you will certainly find yourself thinking about it for a long time afterwards.

‘Nocturnal Animals’ is currently showing at Tyneside Cinema, Newcastle.

Photograph: GabboT