Hollywood, where have our complicated girls gone?
By Eloise Pearson
This article contains spoilers for ‘The Girl on the Train’ and ‘Gone Girl’.
A miserable Sunday evening and I ventured out into the Durham drizzle for a long overdue trip to the Gala and a nice night of escapism from start of term blues. I had been anticipating The Girl on the Train for a while now: the endless comparisons to 2014’s Gone Girl had me itching to see it, and honestly I am just a sucker for films that look like they’re about bad women.
I am absolutely mad for thrillers staring complicated female leads. Just the right amount of relatable badness. The tense score. The near darkness shots and vague, spine tingling trailer quotes. Women we don’t know if we can trust. We don’t know if we can let ourselves like. With justifications just fitting enough.
I don’t mean gun-slinging, sexed-up Harley Quinn or women forced into hardship through the remorselessness of their male counterparts. I am not about crazy exes, no bunny boilers or man-eating vampires – I mean women so realistically bad they could be the woman sat next to you on the bus.
This is what ultimately placed Gone Girl in my top twenty contemporary reads (which is a hard spot to grab for someone doing a Lit degree). I love Flynn because she doesn’t apologise for Amy’s badness, she doesn’t make the narrative explain it away or fetishize it. Flynn knows that sometimes women are bad just like men are bad – with the same emotional intensity and the same unreasonable, unchangeable personality.
Unfortunately, it is just not something I find very often and maybe that’s why I cling to it with such enthusiasm when I do. Don’t get me wrong, I don’t endorse framing your husband for murder or committing unspeakable acts of violence with a box cutter. I just want a plot about a female character to be more than the sum of her relationship to, or indeed performance for, men.
And it is in this way The Girl on the Train let me down the most.
Don’t get me wrong; I still think that it is well worth a watch.  Blunt is a commanding lead and the script is full of emotional intensity, even if it is not entirely faithful to the book. The ending, however, was just highly disappointing.
I felt that all the complexity was just slowly drained from the plot. At first the film attributes actions to a strong female lead that, for me, were refreshing to watch in mainstream cinema. Rachel is represented in scenes of alcoholism, aggression and domestic abuse in a completely unromanticised way. She is psychologically detailed and compelling to watch. She is the woman representing darkness completely on her own. Her character is far beyond problematic. She rages and screams and the audience feels uncomfortable in the best possible way.
The ending undercuts this almost entirely. Of course, Rachel could not have been bad entirely on her own. This simply wouldn’t sell. The film needs a convenient villain. The heroine needs to find hope in the end. The final scene sees her hair re-curled, her makeup back on, her clothes new and shiny. She has finally overcome the male obstacle in her life and can now return to being a stereotypical waif on a train.
Women having problems; women being bad; doing complicated actions for complicated reasons. This is what Hollywood needs more of and this film was certainly not it.
It seems to me that the film industry needs to take a good look around and realise that women feel exactly as men feel. That sometimes women’s problems and psychological complexities do not always come down to the manipulation of a man.
We need to escape the tired tropes of innocent waif driven to madness or unapologetic whore, bad in her black leather, caressing her phallic guns. But more than this. We need genuinely complicated women. We need female characters who speak to the real complex variety of women in the world. We need them to be ultimately human and I feel like this was simply a half effort. A step in the right direction, but not nearly enough.
‘Gone Girl’ is available on Netflix; catch ‘The Girl on the Train’ at the Gala Cinema.
Photograph: Courtesy of eOne
