New Perspectives: Striking the Balance with the EU

by Tobias Thornes

‘Shackled to a corpse’. That was the morbid description of the UK’s relationship with the European Union given by Conservative MP Douglas Carswell on Friday, whilst announcing a private bill calling for the country to revoke its 1972 agreement to join the political and economic alliance. He regards the Union as an economic drain, claiming that Britain’s rising contribution to EU funds could be better spent domestically.

Such remarks are surely bound to invoke anger amongst some of his Liberal Democrat allies in government, who have always been the strongest backers of the UK’s membership. Carswell is, however, far from alone in his views: surveys suggest that the general public is becoming increasingly disillusioned with the EU, and the suggestion of an ‘in/out’ referendum is being heard increasingly within political circles.

But a general referendum on the subject is, surely, not the way forward. At a time when global issues such as climate change require all our efforts to deal with, the notion of withdrawing from political cooperation with our neighbours seems a suicidal one.

After all, how are we to encourage foreign countries to follow our lead – be it on the environmental or economic  stage – if we send out the message of isolationism that actively withdrawing from the EU would undoubtedly create? We should be concentrating all our efforts on revolutionising the unsustainable practises currently endemic across our society, not wasting our time asking whether or not to needlessly offend our neighbours on the continent.

At the same time, though, an all-out embrace of European leadership is not desirable if we are to make the revolutionary changes needed in our society to reduce our impact on the environment and obtain a more equal and satisfactory social structure. We have already seen how countries such as Greece have been affected by an even deeper envelopment than our own within the European community, as members of the Eurozone.

Here, in the very home of democracy, a very undemocratic ousting of the socialist Prime Minister George Papandreou by German and French leaders followed the country’s collapse into financial difficulty in 2011. The elected leader was effectively forced to resign by European overlords who, having control of his country’s currency, saw fit to dictate the course of its politics.

The European powers-that-be are, largely, capitalist. They were unwilling to see the necessity of his government’s public spending programme for the wellbeing of its people, instead focusing on the monetary cost of his policies. Greece had the people and the resources in place to deliver help to members of its society in need. What it lacked was simply money, that arbitrary quantity invented to help society to function, not to hinder it.

But because its money supply was under the control of Europe, Greece was unable to put aside the debt that existed on paper, and was therefore forced to make its people suffer – through a cutting back of public services far more severe than Papandreou had been willing to implement since his 2009 inauguration – in practice. This would not have happened to an independent country under socialist leadership.

The UK, then, has much to learn from recent European events. To join the Euro, there are few who would disagree at the present time, would be disastrous, as it would remove our ability to decide our own attitude towards money and hence to make our own political decisions.

Even in our position outside the Euro-zone, we must not allow a capitalist European consensus – which exists despite the election of a nominally socialist president in France – to prevent our revolutionising our society and freeing it from the dictatorship of money. Britain has to assert its rights as an independent power, so as to maintain the ability to bring about great change within our own society and shift away from capitalist priorities if this is what our people desire. If a socialist government is formed following the next general election, it needs the power to act.

But at the same time, we need to encourage other countries to follow our lead if we are successful in building a more sustainable and fairer society. We cannot alone avert the problems of climate change and an over-obsession with monetary concerns at the cost of our people’s wellbeing and our environment, which currently pervade the capitalist world. A withdrawal from the EU would leave any government of ours – revolutionary or not – with less of a voice abroad. A delicate balance must be struck.

What we need is not a referendum, but a statement asserting our own national independence, within the current structure of the European Union, reaffirming the idea that if our population votes to change the way things work within our society, we will not allow Europe to over-rule the public’s decision and choice of its own government.

Our current government may not agree with the need for revolutionary change, but it must surely agree that we need to have the option, should the country so desire, of bringing it about. We must not become another Greece – another pawn in the European game. We must be independent in our domestic policy, but democratic in our foreign policy. To achieve this, membership of the European Union is essential, to revive the corpse of Europe from its capitalist stupor if nothing else.

Photograph: Xavier Häpe via Flickr