McKinnon verdict bodes well for the future
by David Siesage
For a decade, Asperger’s suffering computer hacker Gary McKinnon has been fighting against an extradition ruling which could have seen him sent to a US prison for around 60 years. This month he won the battle to stay in the UK when Home Secretary Theresa May blocked the extradition on the basis of the Human Rights Act.
Although the US is ‘disappointed’ with this verdict, we should look on this as a positive thing: both a victory for common sense and a step in the right direction towards changing the extradition procedure.
Nonetheless, the reasons behind the decision are complex and somewhat murky.
The irony of May using the Human Rights Act for the greater good is lost on few; this is the same Home Secretary who stated that she’d “personally like to see the Human Rights Act go because I think we’ve had some problems with it.”
Indeed, the human rights aspect of this case does set a worrying precedent. May was only able to stop the extradition using claims that McKinnon would possibly kill himself if extradited; what is to stop even the most incompetent of lawyers claiming their client is on the brink of suicide?
And why save McKinnon and not fellow Asperger’s sufferer Talha Ahsan? Well, probably because of the terrorism aspect, but the family of Babar Ahmad, one of the five terror suspects including Abu Hamza and Ahsan extradited to the US earlier this month, asked, “Why within the space of two weeks, a British citizen with Asperger’s accused of computer-related activity is not extradited, while two other British citizens, one with Asperger’s, engaged in computer-related activity are extradited? A clear demonstration of double standards.” McKinnon became the focus of a populist campaign movement, and this verdict shows their power.
Speculation has subsequently arisen about May’s actions, some suggesting that in a period of intense governmental scrutiny, this decision could have been for popularity. Former Home Secretary Alan Johnson even claimed her decision was “in her own party’s best interests but it’s not in the best interests of this country.”
It should not have gone this far. The pursuing of this case made America look spiteful and petty as the public perception of McKinnon was that of a troubled and humble computer nerd, whilst US authorities claimed that his conduct was “intentional and calculated to influence and affect the US government by intimidation and coercion.”
Really, the US should be relieved that it was McKinnon, and not someone more dangerous, who broke into their computers and exposed the weaknesses in their security. It is clear that he was no super-criminal and May’s decision is a victory for common sense.
But why the decision was made is less important that the fact that it was at all. One of the most important repercussions of this case is that it has brought these imbalanced extradition procedures to the public consciousness.
There is incongruity in the agreement: whilst the US only need to find ‘reasonable suspicion’ to extradite someone from the UK, British prosecutors need to find ‘probable cause’. Although Sir Scott Baker’s extradition review found no real difference between the two, the semantics imply a worrying inconsistency.
We cannot remain subservient to American whims when it comes to extradition. The Washington Post suggested the ruling “could ignite tensions in an otherwise close transatlantic relationship”, but we must look into the extradition treaty. It was created in 2003 for the purpose of bringing terror suspects to justice, but of the 63 extraditions between 2003 and 2009, only one was a terrorist. Thankfully, in the wake of the Abu Hamza case, May vowed to review the process.
Thus despite the complex and not universally positive reasons behind May’s decision to block the extradition, it is a blessing for the future of extradition legislation, if not the future of transatlantic relations.

