My city is dead to me – for now
By Joe Cannon
Content warning: this article contains mentions of suicide, which may be triggering to some readers. Discretion is advised.
Among my most prized possessions is an original press of Joy Division’s seminal album, Unknown Pleasures. It’s the stuff of legend. Though eclipsed by later single Love Will Tear Us Apart in the halls of Mancunian culture, the record’s reputation precedes it. Clouded in mythos and incessantly reproduced on t-shirts, the spectral image of the cover is all that many know of it. But behind the sleeve is forty minutes of icy basslines paired with equally brooding and bare lyrics. For most, the lyrics represent a glance into the troubled life of frontman Ian Curtis; with tracks like “New Dawn Fades” foreshadowing his tragic suicide at the age of 23, you can certainly see that. But, for me, the connection is very different. Unknown Pleasures is an album that represents both the culmination of the grim Mancunian 1970s and a band at the cusp of greatness. But the vinyl itself is my generational link to that past Manchester; from my dad, growing up in the 1970s at the same time as the future bandmates of Joy Division, to me, in the 2010s and 2020s.
Nostalgia is a strong force, and though Manchester innovated in the 1980s, it also sold its soul to the devil in the process
The same old story played out across the ex-industrial towns of the North. On the cusp of the 1980s, Manchester ended the decade in no better a place than it had started it. At its beginning, author W.G. Sebald framed the barren environment of the city in apocalyptic terms as “Elysian fields”. Slum clearances were at the top of the urban agenda, and Manchester – as the world’s first industrial-capitalist city, with its inequality inspiring the work of Marx and Engels – had plenty to go around. Those Elysian fields represented the knocked-down slums that were never replaced, but in other places, coal-coloured tower blocks were what went up to replace them, slicing open communities with a cut of their sharp edges. Where compromises were made, as in Moss Side, hastily built prefabs with flammable internal walls that bred vermin replaced the redbrick terraces. In other places, the terraces remained; boarded up, of course. Overnight, a community lost its bonds, and a city that had been at the forefront of innovation refused to tap into its people for its new path. The cultural fabric had been torn open, and though some elements of the old industrial environment remained, they were grim façades that hid the spilt guts of the dying industrial city.
The Mancunians of the 1970s grew up and roused themselves from the city’s slumber – then built it up again from nothing, in their image
This was the Manchester of my dad’s youth, and the Manchester of Ian Curtis likewise. It isn’t a shock that Unknown Pleasures is such a cold album in many ways. Songs like “Shadowplay”, tracing the speaker’s route through a grim and shadowy city in the depths of night, reflected the end of industry. There, in Manchester, the cradle of industrial capitalism had become its grave, and its untimely death shook the very foundations of the city. By the time he was seven, my dad had moved between seven different houses. Manchester, of course, never took anything lying down. The city was home to the New Urban Left of the 1970s, remaining ever resistant to the emerging policy of a Thatcherite England, and the pool of creative energies was eventually tapped in a whole slew of different ways. By the next decade, Manchester became a household name in fringe culture, home to Joy Division’s successors (New Order) and bands like The Smiths alike. The Mancunians of the 1970s grew up and roused themselves from the city’s slumber – then built it up again from nothing, in their image.
They drive out local businesses and local people and gentrify the places we once called our own
But that Manchester is gone. It was murdered. In the 1970s, Manchester was a swirling and untapped pool of cultural capital and forgot its innovative roots. Now, in the 2020s, we are forgetting what it is to be Mancunian. Nostalgia is a strong force, and though Manchester innovated in the 1980s, it also sold its soul to the devil in the process. Mancunians recognize their own heritage, but it is a diluted heritage. The memory of left-wing activism in the 1970s (against the slums, against Thatcher) has been forgotten. Instead, our memories are redirected to the halcyon days of the 1980s – to the Hacienda, to the Tony Wilson narrative. Our city’s culture has become a commodity, nicely repackaged for investors. All the while, skyrocketing rents go underreported. Property developers drive out local businesses and local people and gentrify the places we once called our own. Steel and glass have replaced the concrete towers of my dad’s generation. But they fill the same function as before; they rid us of a truly Mancunian environment. The mills of old remain, but renter capitalism has weaponized them against us. We are in mortal danger of becoming a little London, except with worker-bees. We are being made into any other city.
It’s why the city is dead to me, for now. If the people of the 1970s could do something about it, though, so can we. We stand at the same cultural crossroads, after all – we inherit a Manchester with no sense of itself, but which clamours to remain independent.
Image credit: Olivia Krishnan

