Durham Council buys from Chinese tech company linked with repression of Uyghurs

By Palatinate Investigations

Durham Council buys from Chinese tech company linked with repression of Uyghurs

A Palatinate investigation has revealed that a Chinese state-owned technology group, Hikvision, has manufactured 34 cameras in County Durham. In October, Durham County Council announced that it spent £141,840 to upgrade CCTV cameras to create a “safer” environment for “residents and businesses”.

The UK government partially banned Hikvision in 2022 due to its alleged links with human rights abuses in Xinjiang, in which it aided the oppression of the Uyghur minority in “re-education camps”. The partial ban meant that whilst the cameras are prohibited from government buildings, they can still be used in public authorities and police stations. Hikvision is the largest camera manufacturer globally.

In 2021, the UK Foreign Affairs Committee found that Hikvision cameras were “the primary camera technology used in the internment camps”. In the camps, it is reported that Uyghurs have faced sexual abuse, torture and forced labour. The Chinese state denies this, arguing the camps are used to prevent the emergence of terrorism and extreme views.

Following these reports, the President of the World Uyghur Congress advocacy group, Dolkun Isa, told The Guardian, “The goal of these surveillance tactics is not only to instil fear in Uyghurs’ minds that every aspect of their behaviour is monitored but most importantly to single out Uyghurs for detention in the internment camp system”.

Although Hikvision continues to deny these accusations, telling the BBC in 2023 that it is “committed to upholding the highest standards and respect for human rights”, further evidence found by Amnesty International showed that Hikvision cameras are present in the West Bank and the Gaza Strip and used by “Israeli police and private settlers” to monitor Palestinians.

Nationally, there is no council consensus about the surveillance manufacturer – 22 councils and the SNP have committed to phasing out the purchase of Hikvision.

Durham Police and Crime Commissioner Joy Allen stated that CCTV in county Durham was upgraded as “residents and businesses have repeatedly stressed that CCTV cameras make them feel safer”; Councillor John Shuttleworth told the BBC that “higher definition cameras […] capture clearer images, making it easier for CCTV operators to monitor, detect and prevent crime and anti-social behaviour”.

The 34 Hikvision cameras bought by the council do not use facial recognition or artificial intelligence.

Estimated at ÂŁ4,171 per camera, Michael Kelleher, head of planning and housing at Durham County Council, said: “We use cameras from a range of manufacturers as part of our public space CCTV network. We follow relevant legislation and Government guidance in this regard.

“While we are aware of a ban on the use of Hikvision products at ‘sensitive sites’ across the UK for security reasons, local authorities are among the public sector bodies allowed to continue using them to support community safety and the prevention and detection of crime.” The cameras were updated to assist in the prevention of violence against women and girls, which was declared a national emergency by the National Police Chiefs’ Council and the College of Policing.

Mr Kelleher continued, “We will, of course, review our position should legislation and/or Government guidance change in relation to this matter.”

Image: Hustvedt/Wikimedia Commons