MPs warn Government over flawed higher education reform
MPs fear that the Government’s proposals threaten social mobility, a parliamentary select committee report has revealed.
This report marks the culmination of the select committee’s period of scrutiny and consultation prompted by the Government’s higher education white paper of June 2011. It also marks another embarrassing episode for the Coalition Government in its controversial decision to reform the university sector.
The committee’s cross-party membership has warned that instead of breaking the barriers to social mobility, as the grand rhetoric of the Coalition Government claims, its proposals will create a two-tier university system serving to perpetuate society’s inequalities.
This path to polarisation within higher education provision is well on the way due to the decision to let universities admit unlimited numbers of the best performing students achieving AAB at A-Level whilst simultaneously auctioning off 20,000 student places to those institutions charging fees of £7,500 or less.
The introduction of this market-based approach has prompted concern not only on the part of the select committee for the Department for Business, Innovation and Skills, but also universities. As Adrian Bailey MP, the Labour Party chairman of the select committee has stated: “If you ask universities what it is they would most like, it is that they would like these changes deferred” until the effect of the fee increase on student numbers is more plainly visible.
For universities, the crux of the problem is that they do not know how much money they will have available next year because this is directly determined by their student intake.
Many universities have become fearful of their future, particularly middle-ranking ones, leading to a dramatic re-calculation on the part of many institutions across the country regarding their intended fee levels for 2012.
Whilst the lowering of tuition fees by 27 universities is a cause for celebration amongst students, the committee members have highlighted the negative impact the recruitment of unlimited numbers of AAB students and the auctioning of 20,000 student places may be expected to have on social mobility.
MPs have voiced their concern that this will have the result of channelling more students, particularly those with lower grades, into low cost models of education and are fearful that this could create two potentially very different standards of student experience, particularly in strategically important subject areas such as Science and Engineering which are notoriously more expensive to teach.
This problem with this approach is that the proportion of pupils achieving the top grades at A-Level is significantly higher in both independent and academically selective schools, a fact acknowledged by Sir Martin Harris, the former Director of the Office for Fair Access (OFFA).
This illustrates is the ability for universities to admit unlimited numbers of AAB students is likely to favour those with a privileged educational background at the expense of their more disadvantaged counterparts.
To combat this, Universities Minister David Willetts proclaimed: “We have told universities to be much more ambitious with their plans for attracting people from low-income backgrounds”.
However, as recent research by the Russell Group of Universities has indicated, the real barriers facing disadvantaged students are underachievement at school combined with and compounded by poor advice on the best choice of A-Level subjects, as many students find themselves studying subjects that are not accepted by the country’s top universities.
The Government’s reforms are subsequently attempting to retrospectively address an issue that needs to be tackled much earlier in the education system if the root of the problem is to be solved and participation in higher education effectively widened.
Until this occurs, the Government’s proposals are likely to lead to a polarisation within the university sector that will work to the detriment of those from lower socio-economic backgrounds, despite ministers’ claims that the plans will mean a better deal for poorer students.
Even those from such backgrounds that are able to meet the entry requirements of top universities, MPs worry may feel constrained to choose low cost alternatives rather than face the prospect of a £9,000 p.a. debt in tuition fees.
Consequently, the committee has urged the Government to closely monitor the social mix at universities and take swift action if a two-tier system of this sort emerges.

