Miss Julie: the price of pride and shame
Sofya Grebenkina talks to the cast and crew of Pitch Productions’ upcoming production of ‘Miss Julie’.
Miss Julie is August Strindberg’s famous 19th century naturalistic drama, no stranger to the English Literature syllabus or the Western canon at large. It is a psychologically-involved play about the power relations between Miss Julie and her valet, Jean. It is a brief but intense glimpse into the lives of two individuals, who typify the contemporary problems facing their respective sex and class.
Isabelle Culkin, its director, describes the production as a new experience for her. She immediately took a liking to it on her first reading of the play, the appeal being that it is “like Ibsen on crack”. Furthermore, despite the playwright’s clear instructions about the vision behind the production elucidated in his Preface to the work, Culkin sees this as an opportunity to create something “completely opposite to his intentions”. The over-arching creative vision is to embody a relationship obsessed with “pride and shame”, where both partners are loath to relinquish their authority over the other.
The venue of The Assembly Rooms Theatre is theoretically a difficult space to adapt to the needs of such an intimate production, with only the two leading roles commanding the audience’s attention for most of the drama. However, Culkin believes that she has managed to work this to her advantage. “The movement when Miss Julie and Jean come together and they fall apart, physically asserting their dominance, really supports the script.” She concludes that their conflict would not have the same effect if there were more actors present on stage.
Despite her excitement over dramatizing the conflict of power, Culkin is unnerved by Strindberg’s display of overt misogynistic sensibilities. However, she believes that it is “a first director’s dream, because it is not obvious how you should do it”. On an aesthetic level, this means that it creates the peculiar dynamic that Miss Julie can appear to be “fighting against Jean and the intentions of her playwright”. From the audience’s perspective, the misogyny can “challenge the idea of sexual shame, consent and the culture of slut-shaming” that is still a prevalent contemporary issue. The ambiguity of what happens off-stage between Miss Julie and Jean serves to further this debate, as a reflection of the idea that there are no clear solutions when two diverging perspectives over sexual relations collide.

To preserve this feeling of ambiguity within the audience’s mind, it is necessary to create some sympathy even around the rather antagonistic character of Jean. Luke Maskell, playing Jean, feels that the scenes between him and his fiancée are ones in which an audience are likely to see the most pleasant side of the character. However, Maskell also notices that a disturbing dynamic emerges; that “the more she [Miss Julie] gives him, the more he takes”, which will leave the audience unsettled to say the least. Culkin contends entirely that the play demands sympathy from the audience: “I don’t think any of the characters are completely likeable.” The play is rather a meditation on the cruelty of circumstance than a didactic exemplum, leaving even the wronged fiancée of Jean appearing somewhat cold and distanced.
Nevertheless, the actors have managed to extract from the characters something to which they can relate. Maskell admires the “ambition in Jean and the need to better yourself”. In coming to terms with the role, despite its many incongruities with his own personality, Maskell found that “it’s inhuman if you act a role and don’t project a little” of yourself. Eliza Cummings-Cove, playing Miss Julie, agrees. “No matter what character I play it essentially becomes me.” This makes the production particularly unique to the specific actors. To further humanize it, as in the teachings of Stanislavski, Maskell has found it useful to “invent context” for his character.
Whilst observing an initial run-through of the first half of the play, the unique nature of the production was already evident in the actors’ characterization. Jean, who on the page had appeared to me dry and unforgiving, was now given a human edge. As Maskell’s brow creased with worry and anxiety over his lot in life and his conversation with Miss Julie, it was impossible not to feel an ache of empathy in my heart. Meanwhile Miss Julie, who had originally startled me with an incongruous naivety, in Cummings-Cove’s representation, appeared to be calculating, and at the same time speeding on her fall. It was understandable that the ennui of her position had led to this moment of unprecedented risk. Combined with the pregnant pauses, allowing me to savour the meaning of each line, even at this early stage of rehearsal, the atmosphere is already riddled with sexual tension.
Pitch Productions’ Miss Julie has then already offered enough reasons to make me believe that this will be an enjoyable, if thought-provoking production.
‘Miss Julie’ will be performed from Wed 16 Dec until Fri 18 Dec at The Assembly Rooms Theatre, Durham. Book your tickets here.
Photographs: Samuel Kirkman
