Mary Stuart review: ‘succeeds despite itself’
By Srionti Maitra
Fourth Wall Theatre’s production of Mary Stuart promises to pit not queen against queen, but woman against woman. The play, with its naturalistic acting, stark staging and minimalist style, achieves just that. Mary Stuart presents technical mastery that makes good use of the scope that The Assembly Rooms Theatre provides. At its epicentre is the story of the intrigue surrounding Mary, Queen of Scots’ execution. This gender-blind production uses Peter Oswald’s crisp prose translation of the original five act German play, written entirely in verse by Friedrich Schiller.
The protagonists are the heart of the play. As director Penny Babakhani says, the play could just as easily be called Mary and Elizabeth, or Elizabeth I. Emilie Aspeling as Mary Stuart is dignified and stoic. While she does not carry an aura with her at all times, she does exhibit brief flashes of complete mastery over the character’s mind. She ripples with power as she stares down her cousin – the words “I am your queen” resound. Her passion blooms over the acts, with her performance gaining colour and vitality, convincing us that she has indeed “drunk a river of bliss” – that she is a woman before a monarch. Her conviction in her monarchical power, however, is impenetrable. One wishes more music had punctuated her performance to intensify the pathos of her situation. Besides a strange habit of clutching at her skirts, and the rather frantic pace of the scene preceding her death, Aspeling as Mary Stuart is magnificent.
The undeniable star of the show is Jasmine Price as Elizabeth I – a flabbergasting performance from a fresher in her first DST play. She is irreproachable. Her casual regality in company and her solitary distress at being imprisoned by the “will of kings” is heightened by her consistent vocal modulation and assertive movement. She is in turns affected, exhausted, torn, and caustic. Her eyebrows at times threaten to disappear into her hairline as she rolls her eyes. Characterized as soft but squared when needed, Elizabeth’s stature crumbles visibly throughout the play as her jealousy for Mary’s independence even when imprisoned becomes apparent. Price plays the second side of the queenly coin with incredibly nuance. Her deferral of blame for Mary’s undeserved execution, and her subsequent discomfort, seeps through the audience. It is Price who creates a fluid dynamic of love, loss, and power with Aspeling’s Mary. Her standout performance will keep viewers coming back.

The eight supporting characters are in turns ordinary and impressive. Most of them gain a great deal of dimension as the acts progress, no doubt a result of the character building exercises the cast underwent. Charlotte Thomas as Hanna Kennedy, the loyal lady-in-waiting, is a sensible, sleeve-rolling, robust character whose approval I immediately want. I want to shake Hanna’s hand. Her speech flows spontaneously, and her presence creates a great deal of the audience’s sympathy for Mary. Rohan Perumatantri as Mortimer starts out as inspired, but uninspiring. Over time, his character’s motivations morph, and the ugliness of spirit looks good on him. Perumatantri is compelling in the harrowing scene where he attempts to possess Mary, but underwhelming as Mortimer commits suicide. His apostrophe to the throne creates a wonderful sense of metonymy.
Sandy Thin as the Earl of Shrewsbury is distinguished, with the vibe of a wise old professor, though his character’s old age was not accentuated with stage makeup. One must be sure not to cut oneself on Lord Burleigh’s razor sharp wit: Matt Dormer plays him effeminate and supercilious, with his delivery as slick as his hair. The Earl of Leicester, a man trapped tragically in Elizabeth’s present and Mary’s past, is played very believably by Tristan Robinson. Grandeur comes naturally to him, and as his cape billows into the wings, we are not left with a caricature, but a conflicted courtier. His monologue of shameful regret was not exquisitely moving, but served its purpose in the play. He and Mortimer play off each other well. Director Babakhani’s choices in blocking and creating lines between characters balances the play beautifully; there is no awkwardness though the stage is well populated, and particularly in court, there is a sense of being surrounded in a wide space.
Erin Welch as Count Aubespine/Melvil is a convincingly slimy diplomat in the first half and a solemn pillar for Mary at the end of the play; the scene where he bestows the final sacraments upon her is one of Aspeling’s finest onstage instances. Adam Evans as Paulet lacked vigour to begin with, though he gains a quiet solidness by the end of the play. Flora Mitchell as Davison made an effort, but spoke in one tone, and without the subtlety shown by her cast members.
The production team deserves nothing but complete adulation. Even before the curtain rises, the delicate tones of a harp float melancholically across the stage and the seating. Sophie Brown’s musical direction elevates the play hugely, and perhaps the cleverest moment in the production is the breaking of the fourth wall (I mentally punched the air) in the last line spoken: the cast exeunt sans Elizabeth, and Brown appears from behind the panorama, sheet music in hand, informing Elizabeth that her Earl of Leicester has left the country. Though the music appears at some critical moments and not others, whenever it is present, the value of the onstage presence swells. The absence of it at junctures like Elizabeth’s monologue to herself about the dreariness of rule is sharp – the bell that Elizabeth rings for the death warrant is Mary’s death knell; that one sound is made momentous by the lack of anything else.

As a solitary desk and chair is suffused with angled golden light in the first scene, I am already scribbling fierce notes about Jonathan Salmon’s brilliant use of lighting, and will continue to do so for the rest of the three acts. The shallowly lit, blue-tinged claustrophobia of Mary’s cell versus the soaring green tones of the ‘forest’, represented by nothing but intelligent stagecraft, erases the need for elaborate props and draws attention constantly to the main characters.
The Elizabethan court is stripped of any and all opulent trappings; Mary’s poor desk is Elizabeth’s throne in the second scene. Babakhani explains that this hones in on the similarities between the two women, rather than the differences between the two queens. All characters but the female leads are rendered in black and white. Elizabeth I appears in jewel tones and Mary in subdued navies and cream, but the costumes of both have a quiet splendour well set against the uniformity of the courtiers: congratulations are in order for costume designer Laura Littlefair.
If only everything had gone as smoothly as the pantaloons! The dialogue of the first act stumbled along like a Renaissance carriage, and though it smoothed out considerably over the course of the play, there were moments when quips and climactic speeches were butchered by bad delivery. It was surprising to be informed that several halts in speech were deliberate and not simply garbled lines. Nearly every cast member fumbled at a few points. Other than this, the body language of the characters seemed to seesaw between scant and befittingly restrained. The production is no doubt anachronistic, and does not adhere to Elizabethan rules of conduct, but it is at times, quite literally, difficult to know where the characters stand.
The play and cast did not wring with emotion the beating hearts of the audience, but succeeds despite itself, and is thoroughly enjoyable due to its dripping sarcasm and occasional gravity. Clean dialogue delivered unaffectedly (except where requisite) makes it an engaging experience replete with the “sass” that the programme mentions no less than seven times. Hopefully cured of its case of first-night jitters, Fourth Wall Theatre’s production of Mary Stuart makes this viewer optimistic about the group’s future.
‘Mary Stuart’ will be performed until Sat 12 Dec at The Assembly Rooms Theatre, Durham. Book your tickets here.
Photographs: Samuel Kirkman
