Milei makes waves: Argentina’s new ‘libertarian’ president

By Ross Hyde

On Sunday 19th November, Argentines elected Javier Milei, variously described as ‘anarcho-capitalist’, ‘libertarian’ and ‘state slasher’, to the Presidency of the Latin American nation. Compared by many to Donald Trump, his slogan ‘Make Argentina Great Again’ was perhaps not the most original. A comparison to Brazil’s former president Jair Bolsonaro, who led the country from 2019 until 2022, is also well-grounded; both put forth questionable comments about their countries’ respective military dictatorships of the past. 

However, despite his eccentricity, his chainsaw-wielding antics and his radical economic pledges, his victory is unsurprising. Argentina’s poverty rate rose above 40% in the first half of 2023. Annual inflation in Argentina currently sits at 140%, is rising and is only predicted to continue on that course. Despite Argentina’s central bank (BCRA) capping their citizens’ dollar withdrawals to $200 per month, there is a thriving black market for the American currency which has led to many property purchases being made in the dollar, not the Argentinian peso. Hence, the country’s economy is one in dire need of rescue, and Mr Milei has painted himself out as the man of the hour. 

What does he propose to do? During his campaign, one of his main pledges was to dollarise the economy – ditch the hyper-inflated peso and adopt the US dollar as Argentina’s official currency, as has been done with former currencies in Ecuador, El Salvador and Panama – and abolish the central bank in the process. He also promised to get rid of multiple government ministries, privatise many state-owned companies, cut public spending by 15% (hence the symbolic chainsaw at one of his rallies) and cut ties to ‘communist’ countries. 

Argentina’s poverty rate rose above 40% in the first half of 2023

Without any compromise, the president-elect will run into issues soon after he takes office on December 10. Argentina is a presidential republic, but the president requires congressional approval for economic policies, which have been the centrepiece of Milei’s campaign. Dollarisation has already been put on the back burner. Following congressional elections, his party ‘Liberty Advances’ holds 38 of 257 seats in the lower house, the Chamber of Deputies, and just 8 of 72 seats in the upper house, the Senate. This means he must count on another party’s support to get any desired measures through Congress. This is likely to be the party of Mauricio Macri, part of the big-tent ‘Together for Change’. 

Mr Macri, who served as President from 2015 until 2019, gave Milei an all-important endorsement in October which helped him row to victory in the second round of the election. Macri was ushered into Milei’s campaign headquarters the day after the latter’s victory, and the appointment of several of Macri’s men to powerful positions in Milei’s government – notably Economy Minister – seems inevitable. Yet even if the new president retains the support of the former, he will also require additional votes in the Senate to command a majority, indicating uphill battles to come.

The elections of Milei in Argentina and Geert Wilders, leader of the Dutch right-wing populist Party for Freedom, suggests that desire for radical change amongst the majority of the population could be back

The Argentinians who voted for Milei don’t care about majorities, upper and lower houses, and procedure. They, like many Americans in 2016 with Trump, have voted for a man who has promised he can fix what they perceive to be a bad situation. The election of right-wing populists to government (or the approval of their favoured policies via referendum, as with Brexit in 2016) has been a trend since 2016. The election of Milei in Argentina and Geert Wilders, leader of the Dutch right-wing populist Party for Freedom, suggests that desire for radical change amongst the majority of the population could be back – a test of this will be Trump’s performance in the American presidential election next year.

At the same time, this is not an overwhelming trend. When the next general election is held in the UK, likely next autumn, there will be no major populist party competing. Spain’s recent general election resulted in a decline in support for the right-wing populist party Vox. Milei’s campaign was focused on economic issues, as opposed to the social and cultural issues that dominate most populist campaigns. 

Of course, an article about Argentina in a British newspaper can scarcely be published without a mention of the historic issue between the two countries: the Falkland Islands, or Islas Malvinas to use their Spanish name. Although Milei has reiterated Argentina’s claim to the nearby islands, he has also acknowledged that the islanders’ wishes must be respected. If the 2013 referendum is anything to go by (where a grand total of 3 out of 1,516 Islanders voted to leave the UK), support for joining Argentina is not high. In a phone call between Milei and British Foreign Minister David Cameron following the former’s victory, mutual admiration for Chruchill and Thatcher was reportedly high on the agenda; the Falklands didn’t get a mention. Perhaps it truly is a time of change in Argentina.

Image: Vox España via Flickr