From Arabia with Love: the danger of The Telegraph’s potential new owners
By Vadim Goss
When the UAE’s Vice President Mansour bin Zayed Al Nahyan bought Manchester City in 2008 it signalled a transition: between the Russian oligarchs purchasing British assets, to the Arab Sheiks. At the time, it would have been predictable to see the sportswashing parallels between Abramovich’s takeover of Chelsea with that of Mansour and City. And although this was pointed out at the time, and still is now—about how doing business with countries and individuals with questionable ethics and unforgivable human right records may allow for a propagation of their respective regimes whilst also defacing British institutionalism in the process—in truth, no one really took the matter seriously enough. Fast-forward 15 years later: Abramovich is gone, Mansour is on the rise, and was poised to buy The Telegraph and The Spectator before the Government upheld the buyout. The threat, it seems, of British cache falling under the control of autocratic states, is finally being taken seriously. But is it too late?
Sport was the first stage for the Gulf states in building their international portfolios. For given the unprecedented success of Man City under Mansour’s ownership, the Arab regimes must have clearly seen the untapped potential sport holds in regards to brand. The UAE, Qatar, Saudi Arabia: each of them could now hide their crimes behind the glittering image of a successful, state-owned sport enterprise. Not only that, but this experiment worked twofold in proving not just to be a successful social investment but also an economic one. And soon enough, once they had established their presence in the market the Arabian portfolio expanded from sports to ports, to millions of acres of public land, to apartment blocks all over Britain’s major cities—all privatised under an oil-rich flag, all under the guise of simpatico investment.
Sport was the first stage for the Gulf states in building their international portfolios
Unfortunately as criticisms have grown, paradoxically so has the rate at which these deals have occurred. This has been deliberate, with these deals being sanctioned by a complicit Government who, in acknowledgment of the economy they broke, were obliged to sell-off as quickly as possible to the highest bidder. But naturally because it was Gordon Brown’s Blairite government back in 2008, and a Conservative government since 2010, such deals have been itemised to the degree in which it did not affect “their” people unless for financial benefit. Hence why Mansour was allowed to buy Man City, a club synonymous with the working-class of inner-city Manchester; hence why the Saudi Crown Price bought Newcastle; hence why public land has decreased and unhoused housing has increased. There was no intervention then because it did not invade their personal space. But now, Mansour has gone too far: he’s vying for a beloved, conservative and middle-class institution. For unlike Man City, The Telegraph is (most likely) not supported by Liam Gallagher, but rather, The Prime Minster.
Of course, the Government are right to intervene. The reasons cited are earnest. The Telegraph would risk being censored (The Spectator as well, though good luck trying to tell Rod Liddle that. Unfortunately however The Spectator has not been subject to the same intervention) by an owner who just happens to be a senior leader in a region where repression of the press is convention. The Israel-Palestine conflict; the war in Ukraine—wherein Mansour has recently been accused of helping to hide oligarch assets in the UAE—would surely all be at risk due to the omnipresence of an interested party at the helm. It would betray the freedom of the press that Britain, and any democracy, must protect; and it would result in another tool the Gulf states can use to propagate their regimes through their continued acquisition of established institutions. But the Government had the option to do this sooner. They chose not to. And the reasons why they chose not to I posit is because it never suited them to do so—until now.
Unfortunately as criticisms have grown, paradoxically so has the rate at which these deals have occurred
The Telegraph is the UK’s leading conservative broadsheet—not to suggest it’s a mouthpiece, far from it; but certainly The Telegraph is symbolic of a traditional Conservative face quickly being erased as the party becomes pulled further to the extremities of the right. And although The Telegraph has diverged somewhat to this direction its readership has remained consistent in representing this traditionalism. Simply put then: if the Conservatives failed to protect The Telegraph’s autonomy it would be a bipartisan disaster, to the freedom of the press in this country, and to the core conservatives keen to protect their own institutions.
I suppose one cannot help but feel aggravated that it took so long for this resolution to occur. If football was conservative and/or middle-class then perhaps it can be imagined that Mansour’s Empire would have been stopped before it began. To a government either one or both of these things it didn’t matter too much back in 2008 but it matters now. In reality, it mattered as much in 2008 as it does now. But the deal could still go through, and if it does, we may well expect an irrevocable change to the British media landscape. And if you think Sportwashing’s bad—with football teams become satellite products for authoritarian regimes—history tells us how publications becoming state-owned propaganda machines are so much worse.
Image: Österreichische Außenministerium via Wikimedia Commons

