Mildert JCR President targets exec cliquishness

Neil Crimes, President of the Van Mildert Junior Common Room, has drawn up proposals for wide-ranging reform of the way the JCR is run. The proposals call for radical changes to the operation of not only the executive, but also the various committees, which manage all of Mildert’s student-run activities.

The proposals come in response to accusations of ‘cliquishness’ in the behaviour of some committees. A number of students have complained that committees are run by close-knit groups of friends, or that a number of people are prominently involved in several committees, even though popular committees, such as YPP (Young Persons Project) are always heavily oversubscribed. There have also been complaints concerning the interview process for committee positions, which some Mildert students feel is too intimidating and does not provide adequate feedback.

This can also be seen as part of a wider problem that community spirit at Mildert is seriously absent and that there are few opportunities to get involved. In the student experience survey conducted last year Mildert rank 13th out of the 15 colleges for the sense of community. Further, a recent anonymous survey, conducted by the JCR president, which received nearly 100 replies, revealed that many Mildert students felt there were few opportunities to get involved in college.

Crimes’ reform program is targeted at both problems. By getting people more involved in college he hoped to foster a greater sense of community, while at the same time getting rid of the sense that college is run by cliques. Were the proposals put into operation, they would involve the reduction of the current exec of around ten people to just three positions: president, vice-president and treasurer. Closed exec meetings would be replaced by meetings of all the officers and committee-heads, open to all members of the JCR. Terms of committee positions would be shortened from a year to just one term, and people would only be allowed to serve on one popular committee at a time. However, Crimes has made it clear that these are just suggestions – “a thought experiment” to get people interested in the issue.

The President of St. John’s College, Rebecca Davies, while conceding that her college was very different from Mildert in atmosphere and being much smaller in size, has cautiously welcomed Crimes’ proposals.” I do think that it is necessary that a President does whatever he/she can to improve access to the exec/ decision making process/ running the JCR, so I give Neil my support”

The issue of reform was put to the JCR in a special forum at the end of the JCR meeting on Sunday 18 February. The forum was attended by around 90 members of Mildert’s 900 person strong JCR. Dispute the low turnout Crimes remained optimistic. “The meeting was really productive and it did what I wanted it to do – to start thinking about the issues and work on ways that we can move it forward.”

It was resolved that further consultation with the JCR membership was required before any further action could be taken on the issue.