Durham and Newcastle celebrate 50 fixture

GUESTS, MOSTLY FORMER players, of the Rugby Clubs of Newcastle and Durham universities assembled at Cochrane Park on Saturday February 9th to celebrate the 50th fixture between the two clubs.

Durham-Newcastle fixtures have always been played with intense passion and high skill levels, which is not surprising considering the quality of the players involved. Many future, and even current, internationals have represented these universities. The likes of Marcus Rose, Will Carling, Will Greenwood, Chris Oti, Andy Mullins, Phil de Glanville, Mark Bailey and Fran Clough are among those that have worn Durham’s colours, while Newcastle have fielded teams that included Ken Goodall, Paddy Johns, John Jeffrey and more recently the Best brothers, Simon and Rory. There was once a derby match at Cochrane Park at which there were seven future international players on the field at the same time.

The rivalry between the two universities is rooted deeply in the distant past. Durham University, one of the oldest academic establishments, was founded in 1832 and for well over a century the Newcastle establishments College of Medicine and College of Science were part of it.

The University’s Rugby Club was formed in 1876 and, although it was one of the strongest senior club sides in the region, it was centred on Durham and so tended to be dominated by Durham players. As a result three constituent clubs emerged within the rugby club: Durham Colleges, College of Medicine and College of Science. Sir George Hare Phillipson, Dean of the College of Medicine, presented a special trophy, the Don’s Cup, in the season 1901-02 which was to be awarded to the winners of a knock-out competition between the teams. He started a hotbed of intense competition that lasted for more than 60 years.

The Don’s Cup ended as a tournament in 1963 when Newcastle was given its own charter and the two universities became separate institutions. However rivalry was no means diminished by the reorganisation – indeed if anything it intensified. Matches between Newcastle and Durham teams were always the highlight of the season, attracting large, partisan crowds. Of all the outstanding matches the most memorable and controversial must surely be the final of the of the inter-universities championship in 1969: Durham versus Newcastle at Ashbrooke Stadium, Sunderland. Newcastle had an outstanding team that year, including Ken Goodall, Ireland’s No.8, and Dick Cowman, who would become England’s stand-off. Durham too were certainly no slouchers; Peter Rossborough, the England full-back, was one of several fine players. Unfortunately for the Geordies, Goodall was injured in an international against Scotland and was unavailable, and during the game, Cowman and three other players suffered bad injuries. Since replacements were not allowed in those days, Newcastle were never in with a chance.

There is no doubt that Durham have been the more successful over the years – but then they have had some of the strongest teams ever to play student rugby, for instance there was a period during the late 1970s and early 1980s when they won the inter-universities championship four times in five years. Nevertheless, Newcastle has never been far behind and has certainly had its moments, including a couple of very emphatic victories over their rivals.

Last Saturday’s match was attended by people of several generations. Players, such as Don Heaton, E. Stan Holmes, Dennis Holliday, John Craven, Derek Morgan and Malcolm Martin who played before the 1963 separation, were present. The day was perhaps bewildering for the younger people present at the game. They undoubtedly enjoyed the match itself, which Durham won 18 – 11, but it also gave them a chance to see just what this wonderful game has meant, and still means, to countless former players. They will undoubtedly have their own chance to come back to ‘derby games’ and re-live their experiences when their own playing days are through and it is hoped that the game will still be in the same healthy state when they do so.

Durham University RFC Ted Wood’s vision of the future sees a closer collaboration between the Rugby Academies of senior clubs and the universities:
“My hope for the future is that outstanding young players will seek admission to the best university for them and follow the most rigorous programme they can. If that institution also shares a tradition of rugby excellence then the Academy should support and foster the University tradition rather than detract from it by the recruitment of players except when those players are not required by the university.

I would seek to replace or to run parallel to the Senior BUSA competition’s regional competitions to include Academies, Universities and the Development teams of some Division One clubs. This is the way that Oxford and Cambridge have taken their clubs forward in competitions which are not shaped by a league structure but one in which young players are free to be creative and innovatory.”