Merlin Series 5, Episode 3

by Bryony Hockin

It was a suitably spooky Merlin episode this week, with Arthur receiving the power to speak to the dead.  However his conversation with the ghost of his father Uther (Anthony Head) did not go as planned. Arthur’s character has clearly developed into a strong leader who knows his own mind, but when faced with Uther’s disapproval his many daddy issues raise their ugly heads.

A strange contrast to the deep emotional themes running through the episode is the return of the comic relief and a new power dynamic between Arthur and Merlin, perhaps once more on the level of equals; either way, the duo spend a good portion of the episode bickering their way around the castle slapping each other with spoons and jumping at their own shadows.

I don’t blame Merlin for jumping at his own shadow, though – once the scary events start there’s little respite and soon everyone in the castle becomes a bundle of nerves, twitching at every candle flicker. I myself kept the lights on for at least an hour after the episode finished.

The difference between this mysterious threat and ones in previous series is that rather than being a mere nuisance (see every pixie, imp or goblin Merlin has ever fought) the supernatural creature poses a genuine threat to many of the main characters, deliberately going after the non-noble Knights of the Round Table and targeting Guinevere.

We soon discover the culprit of the supernatural goings-on; none other than Uther, who has escaped through the shiny magical portal at Stonehenge where Arthur first went to speak to him. Furious at Arthur’s leadership decisions, he takes matters into his own ghostly hands by banging lots of doors and throwing axes at knights.  This eventually culminates in a serious attempt on Gwen’s life. The ever-knowledgeable Gaius (Richard Wilson) gives Arthur and Merlin a way of sending Uther back to whence he came; now all they have to do is stop arguing long enough to find him…

After becoming separated from Arthur, Merlin finally plucks up the courage to reveal his magic to Uther’s ghost, displaying more of his new attitudes towards magic.  Should he have to hide it? Is he beginning to sympathise more with Mordred, and especially Morgana? Many Merlin fans have speculated as to if and when Merlin will reveal his magic to Arthur, some with more degrees of frustration than others.

Surely after Arthur uses magic in this episode, and is more obviously forgiving to magic users, Merlin would be more willing to reveal his magic? The answer, I’m afraid, is not today, and I will leave the reason for that as bait to those of you who haven’t yet seen the episode. Go! To iPlayer!

Watch Merlin on BBC Iplayer here

Photograph: BBC