Ed Miliband has finally arrived as Labour leader

by David Hynes

Better late than never, I suppose.

After two long years of disquiet among the ranks and incessant questioning, not to mention innumerable fratricidal references, Ed Miliband has finally arrived as Labour leader.  It was the speech the party faithful had been waiting for, delivered without notes and with a sense of ease few thought he possessed.  Even the right-wing media admitted Miliband had shown a glimpse of the statesman within.

Impressive as the delivery was, it was the term ‘one nation’ which got the pundits chattering.  As many will be aware, ‘one nation’ politics is not a Labour invention; Miliband stole it straight from the lexicon of nineteenth century Tory leader, Benjamin Disraeli.  In his speech, the Labour leader described such a country as one where ‘everyone has a stake…where prosperity is fairly shared’.  It is a sentiment that will resonate with many in modern day Britain.

Perhaps the most surprising fact is the ease with which Cameron himself gave up the ‘one nation’ image he had so carefully tried to craft since becoming leader in 2005.  Cameron was at the heart of the Conservative’s detoxification campaign: he told us to hug a hoodie; he said he cared about the environment; he claimed that ‘we’re all in this together’.  Forget the nasty party, this was compassionate Conservatism.

Which is all fine, except it wasn’t. The toxic Tory was always lurking ominously behind the wafer-thin makeover, and has since returned to ruin Cameron’s efforts. The Conservative image has been severely tarnished by the controversial NHS reform bill and exposure of worrying links to the Murdoch Empire. Leaving aside Cameron’s conference speech, his dart rightwards is amply displayed by the recent cabinet reshuffle: moderates were sent packing and in their place came politicians who would appease the Tory hardliners.

All of which leaves Ed Miliband with a tempting proposition. It would be all too easy to drift to the right with Cameron and try to mop up some of the middle-ground voters the Conservatives have possibly lost due to their change in direction. This would be a mistake. Miliband should remain true to Labour’s history as a party of the left and must endeavour differentiate himself from Cameron.  Unless he does this, the attitude that politicians are all the same – one which currently pervades society – will return to haunt him in the next election.

For Labour supporters, there is reason to be cautiously optimistic.  Jon Cruddas, leader of the party’s policy review, outlined in last month’s New Statesman the direction in which party policy is headed.  In his piece he wrote of how a Labour government would ensure that middle and low-waged workers would get just payment for their efforts and that there would be drives to improve education and high-quality childcare.  Investment would be made in housing and social care institutions to look after an aging population.

So far, so good. However, it’s one thing outlining the party beliefs to a left-leaning magazine; it’s quite another to put these ideas into terms appealing to the electorate.

The truth is that Labour need not do it alone.  Miliband must see himself as not just leader of the Labour Party, but in effect the potential leader of the progressive movement in British politics.  As recent revelations about his contact with Vince Cable reveal, he is well aware that in the Liberal Democrats he has a natural political ally. Similarly, he should make contact with the Green Party.

On the environment, British politicians emit more hot air than China does carbon emissions, but Miliband must surely realise that the future cannot only be red – it must be green as well.  Geographically, Britain is uniquely placed to benefit from wind, tidal and wave power. In an area where we should be exporting technology we are now being left behind, as other countries pour funding into such industries.  The ‘green new deal’ is just one option such an alliance could take to kick-start growth and create employment.

Few would deny that the global left has gone through somewhat of an identity crisis since the 1980s.  The growth of neo-liberalism, spread of globalisation and fall of the Soviet Union sparked attempts worldwide to redefine the political left in new age of freer markets.  The political result? New Labour. The economic result? The seemingly interminable financial crisis.

But the times they are a-changin’.  We’re currently in a double-dip recession, with 2.5 million unemployed, 950,000 of which are young people.  Eleven million people have had no rise in their real incomes since 2003.  We’re living through a period of a great redistribution of wealth, from the poor to the rich.  Tax breaks for the millionaires and benefit reductions for the struggling.  In an economy crying out for Keynesianism, all we get are further cuts.

If the left can’t do well in such circumstances, it is difficult to picture when exactly it can.  Miliband has to believe that the message he’s trying to sell – of a more equal society with a stronger sense of social justice – is one that still resonates with the voter today.  The British electorate deserves better than the patchwork of centrist policies which routinely arise come election time.

Ed Miliband will never possess the rhetoric of Obama, but in his own way he needs to offer the hope the American president so effectively did in his 2008 campaign. It is without doubt a tough task, but for a man whose party slogan is ‘rebuilding Britain’, ambition is clearly not a problem.