Mark Duggan: an imaginary martyr?

By Josh Newmark

It is not often that I find myself in agreement with what the Daily Mail has to say. However, the title of an online opinion article in the wake of the Mark Duggan verdict made a point which I feel that a lot of people are missing: “Mark Duggan was a gangster, not Nelson Mandela.”

Photograph: The London Riots 2011, Raymond Yau
Photograph: The London Riots 2011, Raymond Yau

Although the actual article was filled with unnecessary and rather self-undermining fits of unsubtle snobbery (suggesting that Carol Duggan resembled “Vicky Pollard’s mum”, for example), its title rings true. Suddenly, people have forgotten their concerns about knife and gun crime and cry out against the epidemic of police brutality which blemishes our happy society.

Mark Duggan, aged 29, was shot and killed by police in north London on the 4th August 2011. An inquest into the lawful nature of his killing has ruled that the killing of Duggan was indeed “lawful” provoking outrage in the media and the public.

Firstly, the man did not deserve to die. Like any other human being, he deserved a fair trial. The police made a mistake and should not have opened fire on a man who was not posing an imminent threat.

However, being wronged does not make somebody into a good person, and making a mistake does not make the armed response units some kind of trigger-happy militia – as some seem to be implying.

People are talking about racial-profiling, apparently forgetting that it is not racial-profiling if the person being pursued is an actual criminal being pursued for their actual crimes.

The way that some people are bringing up the tragic shooting of Charles de Menezes in the wake of 7/7 as proof that we are living through an age of constant police brutality illustrates just how short-sighted these police haters actually are.

Two fatal mistakes in eight years, only one of which applied to a totally innocent person, out of hundreds or even thousands of armed-response operations, is obviously never few enough, but is nevertheless an exceptional record and is testament to the high level of training, intelligence, and accountability with which each armed officer is provided.

I can barely believe that I have heard people stating that “innocent people have the right not to worry about being shot by the police” in the wake of the verdict. I have been told that I “must be pretty conservative” for not swallowing this – truly a testament to the strength of the ‘bandwagon’ effect upon the middle-class left.

Iranian demonstrators holding masks bearing the likeness of Mark Duggan. Photograph: Morteza Nikoubazl
Iranian demonstrators holding masks bearing the likeness of Mark Duggan. Photograph: Morteza Nikoubazl

Perhaps people who have not been victims of knife or gun crime ignore the fact that every day innocent people are victimised by armed criminals. They forget that we as a society have demanded a strong response to knife and gun crime and gang violence. They latch onto Carol Duggan’s advice to “lock away your children” from the police, when just a day before the Duggan verdict, it would have been “lock away your children, to protect them from violent crime.”

Mark Duggan should not have been shot, but that does not mean that the police set out intending to shoot him.

People bemoan the “media conjecture” about Duggan himself, while latching onto conjecture about the police’s reasons for shooting him, with very few people actually recognising the Jury’s verdict. The shooting was ruled a mistake, and undoubtedly the police will take steps to try to reduce the chances of another incident like this.

As a society we have accepted that armed response units are a necessity to protect people from armed criminals, and that if you arm yourself, you should expect to be confronted by them. Police marksmen have the right to carry a gun because society has decided on this necessity, and because they are highly trained, supported by intelligence, and bound by rules of engagement and high levels of scrutiny.

Making one mistake does not change this, but it is astonishing to see how many people get so worked up by a narrative of police brutality which is so clearly invented nonsense based on a tiny number of mistakes.

People need to remember how they felt about armed criminals prior to Duggan’s killing, and realise that imaginary causes cannot have martyrs.