Is smoking the new leprosy?
By Josh Newmark
It is somewhat true that tobacco addiction, like leprosy, can be seen as a disease which, left untreated, causes a progressive worsening of the sufferer’s condition, leading their health to decay.
Furthermore, anti-tobacco campaigners are eager to have us believe that tobacco addiction is essentially highly contagious due to the ‘ease’ with which children can become infatuated with the idea of ‘lighting up’.
And so the anti-smoking attitude, in both the public voice and government legislation everywhere, seems to be moving in the direction of forcing smokers into quarantine far away from the innocent and pure folk who do not use tobacco.
But wait a second. Leper colonies have been deemed unnecessary and immoral by Western society for decades! Only for the lepers to be replaced by smokers?
New York City Council’s approval of extending the smoking ban to include electronic cigarettes, is nothing short of a cruel attempt to further alienate smokers.
The e-cigarette allows the user to simulate smoking, getting a suitable amount of nicotine, while inhaling and exhaling only a light vapour: there is no tobacco, no tar, no smoke, and no smell. It is clean, and clear, and under control – there is no second-hand smoke.
They have helped literally tens of thousands of people reduce or even cease their usage of tobacco. The reason they help me personally is because if I can smoke my e-cigarette inside college and inside the pub, odourless and smokeless as it is, I do not need to go outside to the smoking area, and therefore I am not exposed to the temptation of real cigarettes.
However, if my e-cigarette is also to be banished outside to the smoking area, then there is no competition against the real thing. My argument here is therefore to allow e-cigarettes to have this edge over cigarettes. They are currently the best means to reduce tobacco usage.
The New York City ban, and indeed the attempts to limit e-cigarette “proliferation” (like nuclear warheads, or crack cocaine) in the EU, have come alongside declarations that one of the main dangers of e-cigarettes is that “children who could not differentiate between regular and electronic smoking were getting the message that smoking is socially acceptable”.
The term “socially acceptable” is a rather ferocious term to use: why not go to Russia, Greece, or Spain and tell the people there that an integral part of their social life, is actually repugnant and socially unacceptable.
Secondly, e-cigarettes generally emit a blue light, release a small amount of thin vapour, and are often actually black in colour: children, at the age where they might decide to try smoking, are not ignorant enough to get them confused with the white, smelly, smokey cigarettes which are only ever seen outdoors, and it is rather insulting to suggest otherwise.
Now, it might come as a surprise, but smokers are actually human too. We are all aware of the health risks, and most of us will probably try to quit when we are ready. We certainly do not need non-smokers to treat us as if we are being intentionally hostile, and false diagnoses about the reasons why we started smoking are also especially unwelcome.
I first tried it because my friend enjoyed it, and continue to do it because I myself enjoy the relaxing sensation of nicotine – even though I am fully aware that this is just addiction.
However, I am constantly told that I smoke because I ‘want to look cool’. Well, actually, nobody spends £20+ a week, and takes up to an hour out of each day to smoke, purely to ‘look cool’ – the only people I have ever heard refer to smoking as ‘cool’ have been non-smokers trying to explain to me why I smoke, and it made me feel incredibly awkward.
Do not treat smoking like some kind of silly fad which people use to be ‘cool’: it’s not the same as tunnel earrings, or tattoos. It has been a social activity long enough to actually become a ubiquitous part of certain cultures, and so I would suggest that people stop treating smokers like shallow, malicious entities – they have done nothing to warrant it.
Instead of acting vindictively, systematically eliminating every right to use nicotine which we have left, please allow us to use e-cigarettes to cut down our tobacco consumption. Is that not the goal you all want to aim for?
Photograph: Michael Doraushe

