‘Make Me Prime Minister’: TV’s gamification of politics

By Kieran Molloy

The new reality series Make Me Prime Minister is The Apprentice, but for politics. The show pits twelve “ordinary yet opinionated Brits” against each other to see who has “what it takes” to do the top job and take on difficult policy-making challenges. The show is presented and judged by two “political heavyweights” Alastair Campbell and Baroness Sayeeda Warsi.

The stated aim of the show is, according to Baroness Warsi, to “find a new generation of political leaders.” In the run-up to the show’s premiere on Channel 4, there were debates surrounding the gamification of politics, about the risks of reducing its processes to evening entertainment.

Indeed, there is something to be said about this. By stripping politics down to pure personality, and taking away factors like expertise or ideological underpinnings, the show may do a disservice to people’s understanding of the actual political processes in this country.

On the other hand, the show may well serve as a jumping-off point for viewers to develop an interest in the pivotal debates currently underpinning our political climate. This could legitimately fulfil the show’s stated purpose, even if tomorrow’s new leaders are not discovered by the show.

However, the first episode suggests that the programme’s purpose is less to unearth political talent and more to provide a comic fix. It becomes quickly apparent that Alastair Campbell, Baroness Warsi and anyone else involved in the process of creating this show has little interest in uncovering “a new generation of political leaders.” Their main interest is to mock people who are out of their depth.

The audience at home is invited to ridicule these people as they come apart under pressure

The only contestant who has any experience in any level of government is Jackie Weaver, of Handford Parish Council fame; the rest have professions that range from hairdresser to marketing consultant. However, all the contestants seem to share the belief that the solution to any political problem is “just to apply some common sense to what we’re told was a very complex situation.”

This maxim is immediately put to the test as the first task of the series is to fix British primary education with a radical new policy. This is where the inherent cruelty of the premise is most obvious. While the contestants are egotistical or, in many cases, borderline unlikable, their hearts are in the right place. They believe that they can improve and fix the UK. The hosts and producers take no time in punishing them for this belief.

Upon hearing the policies put forward by candidates, Campbell joked that he would not “describe either of those as policies.” Having set a task that political leaders would normally face with the help of civil servants and think tanks, the contestants inevitably come up with half-baked ideas that may sound good at first, but eventually fall apart under the scrutiny of professional journalists.

The audience at home is invited to ridicule these people as they come apart under pressure while carrying out fantasy versions of roles stretching from press officer to prime minister.

Make me Prime Minister is not a show about proving that any “ordinary Brit” can be prime minister as long as they have put their mind to it and apply “common sense”. It is about showing that they can’t. At the show’s heart there are two things: Firstly, there is a deeply cynical exploitation of the UK’s current political situation and the average person’s desire to do something about it. Secondly, there is a technocratic undercurrent that signals to the audience that the average person can’t be prime minister and that we should laugh at those who think that they can be.

Image: Chatham House via Wikimedia Commons