Magritte and the Treachery in Art

by Matteo Schleicher 

René Magritte (1898-1967) was a Belgian surrealist painter. The ‘Centre Georges Pompidou’ in Paris is currently hosting an exhibition on his work under the direction of Didier Ottinger. In this article, I will give my interpretation and will look at the paintings of Magritte through a lens, so to convey the artist’s thinking and challenge the reader’s preconditioned perceptions of reality. In fact, our ‘ordinary’ or ‘common’ idea of reality reads along the following lines: the world around us is mind-independent and external; that is, the objects we see around us exist and truly are as we perceive them through our senses. In other words, the world exists independently from us and does not depend on our perceiving to exist. Magritte, however, argues that in a sense the objects we see around us are not the real objects. He thinks that our senses are deluded and tricked and that images and words do not convey the truth.

To prove that images and words are deceptive representations of the world, Magritte proposes a series of thought-provoking paintings intended to convince the observer of his argument. The main painting associated with this theory is entitled ‘The treachery of images’, which depicts a ‘regular’ pipe. Below the pipe figures the sentence “c’est une pipe”(This is not a pipe). To the observer, this might seem to be a contradiction as the painting truly displays a pipe. Nevertheless, the sentence is correct: the painting is not a pipe but solely a painting, image or representation of a pipe. This is what Magritte means when he says that images are deceptive representations of the world.

Magritte explores the critique of images as ‘betrayers’ of the real world further in other works. In ‘tentative de l’impossible’ (1928), one can see the painter painting a woman in a room. The interesting feature of this painting is that through the ‘incompleteness’ of the woman – the left arm is not yet painted by the ‘painted painter’ – one can perfectly grasp Magritte’s thinking. tentative de l'impossible

In fact, from the observer’s perspective, looking at the left half of the woman’s body, one could think that the woman is ‘real’ – in the painting. Though, looking at the right half of the woman’s body one understands that the body we see is painted – in the painting. That is, if the painted woman would be complete, we would perhaps have mistaken her for a ‘real’ woman – in the painting. This is precisely what Magritte denounces: images do not convey the world as it really is, i.e. if the painted woman’s body would have been complete, we would have taken the woman to be ‘real’ – in the painting – although she is a painted woman – in the painting.

The next painting embodies the extension of Magritte’s critique of images to words. “l’apparition” (1928) presents a man in the foreground, surrounded by words inscribed in dark shapes. The words indeed are the names of the objects that are represented by the dark shapes. The word above the man’s head, for example, means “cloud”, the word on the left side of the painting means “rifle”, or the word on the right side means “horse”. What Magritte is trying to demonstrate with this painting is that words can name things, which do not exist. In fact, as we read the words “cloud”, “rifle”, “horse” we imagine these objects as our mind immediately associates the words to the actual objects. Thus, we get an impression or idea of the painting filled with these real objects. Yet the subsequent impression of the full painting is an illusion: what really populate the painting are single words and not the real objects. This, in turn, is what Magritte means when he says that words are deceptive representations of the world.
la condition humaineUltimately, one could say that Magritte agrees with Plato’s allegory of the cave – i.e. the world we see is not truly out there: our cognition solely seizes representations or ‘shadows’ of the real objects – and explicitly alludes to it in several paintings. The final pieces I have considered, “la belle captive” (1931) and “la condition humaine” (1933) corroborate this view. In both paintings, one can observe a landscape, and in the middle, an easel supporting a painting. The painting perfectly matches the landscape in the background so that one could take the painting to be part of the landscape; indeed, the landscape and the paintings are the ‘same’ thing, the same image. Yet, once again, the paintings are not the actual landscapes but paintings of the landscapes, and therefore representations of the true landscapes.

With these examples, Magritte wants to show that images and words can represent and name things that do not exist in the painting: the pipe does not exist, the cloud, horse, rifle… do not exist, the woman does not exist. Or else, the side of the mountain or the houses we see are neither the real mountain nor the real houses, but ‘images’ of them. This is not to say that the real objects do not exist. It simply says that images and words are deceptive representations of real objects – well at least per Magritte.

Photographs: Creative Common Flikr.