Jose Mourinho appears incapable of inspiring this Manchester United team of ineffective and unstimulating underachievers

By Will Jennings

It’s been eight years since John Terry slipped. Eight years since the Chelsea captain so fatally lost his footing on a wet night in Moscow, enabling Manchester United to regain a sniff in that compelling final of 2008. Eight years since Cristiano Ronaldo leapt like a salmon, remaining in the chilling Russian air for what seemed an eternity to give his side the lead that night. Eight years since Edwin van der Sar’s decisive shootout save confirmed United’s third European glory.

It’s been a turbulent eight years since. The genius of Sir Alex Ferguson engineered three Premier League titles and two further Champions League finals before his 2013 departure, recruiting and developing players of considerable stature such as Nemanja Vidic, Patrice Evra and of course Ronaldo. That side of the 2008-09 epoch was so talented, possessing such palpable unity, desire and ability. How times have changed.

Fergie’s farewell was inevitably going to be so decisive, leaving a sizeable power vacuum at the summit of the Old Trafford hierarchy. Moyes struggled, Van Gaal was derided, and now the ostensible Special One seems so conspicuously incapable of emulating those days of glory under the great Scot. Pity.

This current Manchester United side lacks so much. It lacks leaders, players capable of inspiring each other and fostering atmosphere and unity in the dressing room. It lacks defensive solidity, with the likes of Chris Smalling, Marcos Rojo and Daley Blind delineating their visible ineptitude on so many occasions. It lacks the attacking, free-flowing verve and enterprise that United sides of old possessed in so much abundance, when the likes of Giggs, Ronaldo and even Nani marauded so menacingly down the flanks. It lacks heart.

And Mourinho shows no signs of changing things. Similarly to under the conservative Van Gaal, United move the ball too slowly, playing too laterally and appearing unable to produce the fluid, counter-attacking football that gained them the global reputation they have today. Defensively, the recent injury of the promising Ivorian Eric Baily has inhibited the club’s progress, but his understudies have been so poor. This team possesses no dynamism, no offensive flair that the likes of rivals Manchester City, Liverpool and Arsenal have in so much depth.

Like milk in a student fridge, these players are out of date. Zlatan Ibrahimovic looks visibly fatigued, scorning multiple chances on a frequent basis and often appearing disinterested and apathetic to events around him. Wayne Rooney’s decline has been marked and appears to now be terminal despite his goal scoring efforts against Feyenoord last week, failing to offer the creativity and brilliance that saw him score past Victor Valdes in that Wembley final of 2011. Even a three-year old’s artwork is more creative than Marouane Fellaini.

Anthony Martial and Jesse Lingard should provide a young, hungry and attacking edge to this team, but are struggling to make any form of significant influence under Mourinho. Paul Pogba’s performances of late have failed to inspire, with the bottle-volleying Mourinho seemingly procrastinating in his decision to determine the Frenchman’s most effective position. £89 million? Nonsense.

Whilst United victories over Feyernoord in the Europa League last week and West Ham in the rebranded EFL Cup on Wednesday may have rejuvenated hope amongst the Old Trafford following, they can think again. This side have been appalling in the league so far, conceding four at Stamford Bridge and failing to beat the trio of Stoke, Burnley and West Ham at home. Underachieving? Understatement.

United kicked off on Sunday nine points off the top four. Unless they decipher a way of translating the recent form they’ve demonstrated in these less than illustrious midweek competitions that won’t change.

The problems are manifold. Mourinho’s public criticism of Chris Smalling and Luke Shaw was as impetuous as it was unnecessary, whilst his perplexing reluctance to deploy the services of Henrikh Mhkitaryan – who was superb against West Ham in the cup – baffles fans. Mourinho possesses an ageing and increasingly unenergetic squad who are currently incapable of either defending or attacking with any degree of conviction.

Whilst the Portuguese manager dwells over his bottle-kicking suspension and stringent £16,000 fine, he must consider where he takes this side next. Investment and the promotion of youth is vital, decreasing his side’s fundamental reliance on Ibrahimovic and allowing the likes of Marcus Rashford to flourish. The return of Eric Baily cannot come sooner for United fans, and the employment of the excellent Ander Herrera in midfield has to be sustained.

As it stands, however, Mourinho appears unable to inspire his players. Yes, this squad may contain more baggage than United’s flight to Ukraine will next week, but these players are grossly under-achieving. Fresh faces in January are a must, adding greater depth to this squad that currently lacks so much spirit and vigour.

Change is vital. Mourinho must learn how to derive success from his players whilst simultaneously concluding what his most effective team actually is. He must embrace that sense of entertaining, flowing football that Ferguson promoted so triumphantly. He must tighten up his defence. All these were present in 2008. What United fans would give to go back there now.

Photograph: wikimedia.commons