Longing and belonging on long island

By Scott Batram

H.L. Mencken hated the plot of The Great Gatsby. He dismissed it as a ‘tragic farce’ with ‘a sort of chorus… a bond salesman – symbol of the New America!’ The bond salesman is the narrator, Nick Carraway, and how right Mencken was. The New America was made of money, and so is the novel. ‘Her voice,’ Gatsby says of Daisy, ‘is full of money.’ But money is only half the story. Gatsby is also a book of longing and belonging in the Roaring Twenties, if they were roaring at all.  

Born James Gatz to poor farmers, Gatsby reinvented himself through discipline, effort and cunning, faking it till he made it by flogging prohibited booze: the American Dream incarnate. All of it was for Daisy – but Daisy as she was in 1917, before the war took him away and Tom’s money took her. When Nick warns him that you cannot repeat the past, Gatsby is incredulous: ‘Why of course you can!’ He amassed all his fortune to buy back the lost innocence of youth.

But wealth does not make him happy, or anyone else. The Twenties may have brought electricity, radios, and refrigerators into most urban homes but Fitzgerald’s characters are bored to drink and distraction, drifting pointlessly from party to party, luncheon to luncheon, golf game to golf game. ‘What’ll we do with ourselves this afternoon,’ Daisy asks, ‘and the day after that, and the next thirty years?’ Gatsby’s lawn fills every weekend with strangers drinking his champagne, and he is indifferent. Luxury masks emptiness.

It also masks its victims. Mencken complained that Fitzgerald ‘clears them all off at last by a triple butchery.’ But it matters which three: Myrtle, her husband George Wilson, and Gatsby himself. Two poor, one born poor, and all innocents. Daisy was driving the car that killed Myrtle and Tom was the one sleeping with her, but it is Gatsby whom Wilson shoots. Gatsby’s new money cannot protect him as the Buchanans’ old money protects them. To Tom he will always be ‘Mr. Nobody from Nowhere.’ ‘They were careless people, Tom and Daisy,’ Nick concludes. ‘They smashed up things and creatures and then retreated back into their money… and let other people clean up the mess they had made.’ The Twenties’ hollow prosperity hid its inequality too.

Gatsby is not the only one longing for the past. The Old America, of inherited wealth and lingering Puritanism and Boston Brahmins, wanted itself back: the country it was before the motorcar and jazz and Ellis Island and women’s suffrage. Frightened by the onrush of modernity, the Old America reached for the lock and muzzle: Prohibition to restore its morals, and the Immigration Act of 1924 to pull up the drawbridge. It longed to regain an innocence it believed America had lost.

In doing so, it presaged horrors to come. Tom praises a white supremacist tract by ‘this man Goddard,’ a thin disguise for Lothrop Stoddard’s bestselling The Rising Tide of Color. It is easy to forget how close the old order still was. The Civil War was within living memory; Lincoln’s son lived until 1926, and the year before, the Ku Klux Klan had marched in their tens of thousands through Washington. To men like Tom, the black music that gave the Jazz Age its name (a term Fitzgerald popularised) and the new voices of the Harlem Renaissance were the rising tide of colour made audible. Soon the same pseudoscience would don uniforms and armbands and build death camps across Europe. Gatsby foresees a bleak future as well as mourning a romantic past.

Little of this was new. A nation of immigrants is always fretting about who belongs, welcoming one wave of new arrivals and barring the next. And perhaps that is the timeless tale of the United States: an ugly reality failing to live up to a beautiful ideal, a nation forever east of Eden. ‘All we say to America,’ Dr. Martin Luther King said the night before he was shot, ‘is “Be true to what you said on paper.”’

America claims to have lost its innocence many times: Hiroshima, Kennedy’s assassination, Watergate, 9/11… Perhaps that is because what Americans mean by innocence is a belief that once upon a time it was real – that America once was a city upon a hill. At the novel’s close, Nick imagines Dutch sailors first sighting the New World, ‘face to face for the last time in history with something commensurate to his capacity for wonder.’ The Golden Age is past.

So, were the Twenties roaring? For Gatsby’s guests, yes. But Fitzgerald could hear a whisper beneath the roar: America lost its innocence when it fell in love with money, just as Daisy did. The one character who still believes in its ideals is the self-made Jimmy Gatz, and he believes so sincerely that he cannot see they are gone. The great irony is that Gatsby’s devotion to a careless woman gets him killed, still convinced he can repeat the past. But it is not 1917 anymore.

Image Credit: Paramount Pictures-Famous Players-Lasky (Courtesy of Wikimedia Commons)