Golden Age musicals: utopian nostalgia or subversive innovations?
By Eleanor Waters-Jones
We live in an era of remakes and nostalgia. This begs the question: what deserves to be redone, and what deserves our nostalgia? It appears that the musical theatre community still has more than just a soft spot for so-called ‘Golden Age’ musicals: West Side Story, Kiss Me, Kate, and the like. From the 2021 Spielberg remake of West Side Story, to the 2024 Kiss Me, Kate West End revival (and subsequent pro-shot), we seem to keep being drawn back to this time. But this suggests that these remarkable works provide a sentiment that is timeless and therefore worth recreating – but how do we choose what is ‘worthy’ of endurance?
Stephen Sondheim’s moving Shakespearean West Side Story (1957) takes the audience on a journey through dichotomies of race, class, and gender, witnessing eventual heartbreak of true love in the face of cultural turmoil. In true Sondheim fashion, songs range from the lyrically colourful (‘Gee, Officer Krupke’) to the sweeping and emotional (‘Maria’; ‘Somewhere’). The dance number ‘America’ brings a melting pot of brightly-coloured costumes in an otherwise grey and dying landscape of industrialisation, with the song based upon a Mexican dance (the huapanga). Many white audiences in the Golden Age would have been exposed to Latino-Hispanic influences (via theatre or cinema) for quite possibly the first time, as the United States moved from postwar bliss to questioning its future and multi-cultural identity.
But this suggests that these remarkable works provide a sentiment that is timeless and therefore worth recreating – but how do we choose what is ‘worthy’ of endurance?
Maria and her sister Anita’s duet ‘A Boy Like That/I Have A Love’ is especially complex, with seemingly accidental harmonies, overlaps, and clashing tempos that evoke Romeo and Juliet’s themes of oppression, rebellion, and extreme societal polarisation. However, Sondheim goes further, complexifying hierarchies: ‘Romeo’ (Tony) is a white American man, while ‘Juliet’ (Maria) is an immigrant. Sondheim originally intended for the musical to focus on Catholic-Jewish relations on the East Side, and we might consider how that would have altered the various ‘others’ portrayed. Hence, structures of gender and ethnicity come into play, and although the couple is definitely struggling together against the odds, we can’t simplify moral sentiment as a desire for harmony at all costs. In a 21st century context, we must consider if sympathy should be given equally to all parties, given intersectional disadvantage. On a practical level, how we can achieve the ‘Somewhere’ of racial tolerance, in an age of Reform and Trump?
George Schaefer’s 1958 TV movie Kiss Me, Kate (written, notably, by Bella Spewack, and not her husband) further illuminates and complicates what the Golden Age meant for musical theatre, and Hollywood cinema. It follows Lilli and Fred, who play in a production of The Taming of the Shrew even as they navigate their own ‘shrewish’ marriage. Viewers see numbers performed ‘onstage’ and off it, creating quasi-fourth wall breaks which blur the lines between the characters and their Shakespearean equivalents. Does Shakespeare wave his textual integrity wand here, too? Perhaps not entirely. The play is about systematic abuse and misogyny; though satire may indeed have been employed by the Bard, this is offset by the musical’s catchy songs, euphemistic lyrics (namely ‘Tom, Dick, or Harry’) and slapstick humour. In the end, as Lilli returns to her ‘master’ on the stage after attempting to escape, we aren’t sure what to take seriously. Unlike West Side Story, the boundaries of comedy and parody are blurry: romantic duets (‘Wunderbar’) begin satirically but end with feeling, period costumes are worn in dressing rooms, and the two gangsters appropriate minstrelsy in their metatheatrical ‘Brush Up Your Shakespeare’. This, again, begs the question of audience – in 1958, how cognisant were audiences of the possibility of parody? Which audiences – cinema or theatre? If so, where did they – or do we – draw the line between reality and theatrics?
Paradoxically, therefore, such musicals – and their contexts – question the status quo, the perceived foundation of the Golden Age itself
The iconic lyrics of ‘Brush Up Your Shakespeare’, amongst others, is certainly a reason why this musical has stood the test of time: catchy melodies, the creation of archetypal musical theatre songs and narratives, and what we would think of now as ‘stereotypical’ (often Fossean) choreography. These make Golden Age musicals infinitely restageable. However, this period also treads the balance between tradition – conservative values, Shakespearean language, orchestral scores – and a constantly-developing modernity; between high-art aesthetics and accessible popularism; between theatre and cinema. While Richard Dyer’s “Entertainment and Utopia” argues that the musical form is characterised by facilitating escapism through intense and pure (not necessarily positive) emotion, these two examples also appear to wrestle with a rapidly overt counter-culture movement. Contextually, they provided a snapshot of a time gone by, even as it was happening. Paradoxically, therefore, such musicals – and their contexts – question the status quo, the perceived foundation of the Golden Age itself. They suggest that this Golden Age isn’t so golden after all, and, in so doing, they add to its shine.
Image credit: Store Norske Leksikon

