Lifting the Big Green Smoke: 100 days since COP27

By Rebecca Weir

100 days have passed since COP27, the annual United Nations Climate Change Conference held in Egypt in 2022. This year was particularly significant for the Loss and Damage fund, which was finally agreed after almost three decades of advocacy for climate justice. However, some sceptics have been hesitant to give this too much praise, arguing that this milestone is essentially high-emission nations agreeing to compensate countries for the loss and damage of their own carbon intensive activities. The agricultural sector also had a breakthrough this year, not only dedicating a whole day to agriculture in its 27-year history, but also launching a Sustainable Transformation Initiative to improve climate finance contributions that aim to help transition food systems by 2030.

However, expectations for COP27 were unfortunately not high from the outset, given that the conference was hosted by a dictatorship, the world’s biggest plastic polluter was the principal sponsor (Coca Cola), and more than 600 representatives of fossil fuel companies were in attendance. Whilst it is not surprising that COP27 has not brought the world any closer to tackling the climate emergency, it is surprising that after 27 Conferences of the Parties (COPs), there is still no agreement to reduce fossil fuel use. The causal relationship between fossil fuels and carbon emissions could not be clearer, yet half of anthropogenic carbon emissions have been emitted since the first COP in 1995. 

The conference was hosted by a dictatorship, the world’s biggest plastic polluter was the principal sponsor (Coca Cola), and more than 600 representatives of fossil fuel companies were in attendance

It is these contradictions that are worthy of closer attention. COPs provide an ideal opportunity for fossil fuel representatives to talk to ministers and leaders from all parts of the world and pressure them to give up their fossil fuels for exploitation. For example, during COP25 in 2019, African countries were the target of corporations trying to make a “dash for gas” and get a share of the action, making it all the less surprising that COP has not succeeded in delivering the changes required to avoid climate chaos. This exemplifies the type of corporate lobbying that often occurs during these events, most notably the practice of “greenwashing”. This concept refers to how companies present themselves as more environmentally friendly than they are – often contributing to the crisis whilst positioning themselves as world saviours. Greenwashing is also prevalent in corporate rhetoric and pledges. For instance, the concept of “net zero” is a key discussion point at COPs, with 80% of global carbon emissions now covered by pledges. However the reality of net zero is very different from “zero emissions” – companies can continue to pollute and still claim to have achieved net zero if they can include carbon negative activities on their balance sheet. 

This dynamic is also prevalent in the claims around “green finance” – banks and financial institutions claim to fund renewable energy and climate solutions, yet are simultaneously funding fossil fuel expansion, deforestation, and human rights abuse. Likewise, fossil fuel companies often hype up their “climate friendly” credentials of natural gas – promoting it as a “bridge fuel” to transition to a sustainable future. Yet, this is misleading as natural gas is still highly carbon-intensive and would not prevent the 1.5 degrees of global warming from being exceeded.

Fortunately, there is increasing scrutiny of corporate greenwashing tactics. The UK’s financial watchdog has implemented new strategies to prevent fund managers from misleading consumers about their carbon credentials. Similarly, regulators globally are setting tougher rules on which activities can be considered “environmentally friendly”, whilst activists and campaigners are now taking misleading claims to court. 

The UK’s financial watchdog has implemented new strategies to prevent fund managers from misleading consumers about their carbon credentials

As 100 days pass since COP27, nations and non-state actors will begin preparations for COP28 in the United Arab Emirates next November 2023. This will include designing and operationalising the Loss and Damage Fund, advancing a new quantified climate-finance goal process, and reassessing their obligations under the UNFCCC. However, whilst we continue to make steps towards a lower-carbon future, we must not overlook the greenwashing actions of governing institutions, corporations, and nations – pretending to take climate action may be more dangerous than inaction. 

Image: White House via Wikimedia Commons