Lies, damned lies and statistics
It’s a profound irony that this often used quote is attributed to Benjamin Disraeli; no evidence can be found to suggest that the British Prime Minister wrote this in any of his work. Indeed, the earliest known usage of the term was made years after his death.
What cannot be doubted is the truth behind the words. For several decades, politicians have sought to manipulate information to produce a statistic that will be well received by the public. Whether it is a reduction in the time patients spend on the NHS waiting list, or the nuclear capabilities of WMD in Iraq, it has been shown that public opinion can be swayed by the presentation of certain facts or the dressing up of suspicion into confirmed intelligence reports.
Statistics, however, often conceal the actual truth – not as a result of careful manipulation, but rather by accidence. A football analogy illustrates this perfectly. The record of being England’s highest goal scorer in a calendar year does not belong to any of the prestigious candidates, such as Lineker, Owen or Rooney, that may initially spring to mind. No, the honour is bestowed on Peter Crouch with his 11 goals in 2006. Yet if you included Crouch in a list of England’s greatest strikers you would be laughed at. Despite his robotic dancing and his prolific record, Crouch’s ability continues to be questioned, with pundits recalling that 4 of his goals were scored against Jamaica and Trinidad and Tobago.
This illustrates the problem of accepting statistics at face value. The college points table for sport is a perfect example of this. At the moment Grey sit atop on 1055 points, Collingwood second on 960 and Hild Bede third on 903. At the end of a sporting season, clichés are often heard telling people that the ‘table doesn’t lie’. As a Hild Bede student I know it does – Hild Bede is the greatest college. Yet putting aside my bias, I know this, logically isn’t true either. This is because of the deeply flawed system adopted by Team Durham to judge which college is best.
A little known fact is that college league points are determined by league rather than sport, so that a team win produces 16 points if you play in the Premiership, 8 in Division 1, 5 in Division 2 and 3 in Division 3. On the face of it, this seems like a fair system. Except it isn’t. The points system should be weighed heavily in favour of major sports such as football, netball, rugby and hockey. As it is not, it means that other, less mainstream sports, such as table tennis and ultimate frisbee share equal footing. Both sports are undeniably equally enjoyable and challenging. As President of Hild Bede Table Tennis I should know. Yet, I’m also a player in the 6th college football team and there is something slightly amiss when the success of 2 teams of 6 table tennis players generate more points through their performances than the entirety of the 6 football teams in Hild Bede. Put in even starker terms, 12% of Hild Bede’s college points have been earned by less than 1% of its students.
If major sports were weighted ahead of others, the college league table would undoubtedly look different. Although Hild Bede does have a football team in the promotion pool, it can safely be argued that the college would not be riding high in third position if table tennis had not accrued 112 of the college’s 903 points. As a Hild Beder, this is something of an embarrassment when it is considered we are the largest undergraduate college in Durham. Indeed, when several sports are scrutinised, it becomes obvious that Grey would not be at the top as their position is much to do with the points they have gained from being unbeaten in both the table tennis and ultimate frisbee leagues.
Consequently if you were to weight points to major sports, perhaps defined by the number of players involved across the leagues, it is clear, if unsurprising, which college rises to the top. In the men’s leagues, Collingwood are top of the Premiership for rugby and hockey. Likewise, in the women’s leagues, Collingwood are top of the Premiership for Netball and running a close second at hockey. Considering this success, you may expect Collingwood to be doing slightly better in the college league table. Except they are disadvantaged (admittedly through no fault but their own) in that they don’t have that missing ingredient: a good table tennis club.
As a table tennis player, it’s nice to know that a small personal victory may add up to a greater college tally. Maybe I should just accept that combined ranking tables are often flawed. A quick glance at the FIFA world rankings would lead to the assumption that Greece are the 12th best national side. All football fans know this isn’t true. However, if nothing else, rankings tables are a great way to debate sporting brilliance. Just remember not to rely on the facts.
All information correct as of 4/2/10.
