Letters and responses
Re: ‘DSU and Catholics’, edition 703
There are two key things that we’d love to respond to. The first regarding our attitude towards Roman Catholics. The second with regard to events we run in the DSU, particulalry our series of lunch time talks.
Some misunderstandings have arisen regarding the Christian Union’s view of Roman Catholocism. In a previous article it was stated that our website says ‘DICCU doesn’t believe in Catholics’and ‘DICCU don’t welcome Catholics’.
The statements quoted (one of them actually misquoted) are the list of questions that were posed by Durham students on our Big Question website not, as the comment piece would suggest, statements made by the DICCU.
The Big Question is a series of lunch time talks run by the Christian Union throughout the year, intended to provide the Bible’s answers to Durham students’ questions of faith.
We actually received the most questions on this topic and therefore, after checking with both the Catholic chaplain and University registrar, we put on the event ‘What would Jesus says to Catholics?’ We apologise for any undue offence caused.
The talk given at the event is available on the DICCU website (www.diccu.co.uk). We stand by what the speaker said on our behalf at this event and would ask students who have been given the impression that the DICCU hates Roman Catholics, to go online, listen to the talk and make up their own minds.
Secondly, some questions have been raised about the nature of the events we run, particularly our lunchtime events in the DSU.
The aim of these lunchbars is to provide an open forum for anyone to engage with the claims of Christianity. It is certainly not our aim to prevent people sharing their views or disgreeing with us as we try and present what the bible says.
We hope that anyone who has attended one of these events will have been struck by the manner of the speakers, who always strive to be gracious and gentle; and the atmosphere, which is open and non-threatening.
We always provide the chance for questions, usually by question slips and taking comments directly from the floor.
Time constraints in the lunch hour prevent us running these events as debates with two people from opposing view points speaking. However, if such events were organised, we’d certainly be keen to participate.
It is unfortunate that the Palatinate comment piece reported The Big Question event in such a careless and disingenuious manner. We would ask therefore, on behalf of all student societies, that Palatinate seeks to represent them fairly and accurately in the future.
Paul Oatridge
President of DICCU
Re: ‘St. Cuth’s needs to grow up’, edition 704
I would like to make an important point.
You compare us to the ‘hill’ colleges and say that we should be more like them – better facilities, more “grown up” etc…
That goes precisely against what Cuth’s has always been about. Cuth’s was not set up based on “democracy and equality”, although they are values which we do hold nowadays.
It was set up for students who did not like the rigidity of the college lifestyle. It was for those who did not want to be in Castle or Hatfield – for those who wanted the freedom to live out and still have some form of collegiate experience.
You claim it’s all about “getting pissed”. This is absolutely not true. Cuth’s has always had a reputation for being more raucous than the other colleges, for not necessarily following the rules.
For many this does involve alcohol, although it does not have to. Nobody who does not want to drink has to – there is no “drinking policy”.
However, on the other hand, peer pressure does exist in any society – in ours as well. As our constituents are adults, we do not have the right to tell them not to drink.
We do not have the right to impose our morals upon them. Adults can choose what to do for themselves, and if they can’t then why are they at a world-class university?
Tom Fletcher
St. Cuthbert’s Society
Re: ‘The virtues of the House of Lords’, edition 704
We certainly need an Upper House, but the Lords as it is is not fit for purpose. They may have (rightly) defeated 42 days, but far more importantly they approved the ratification of the Treaty of Lisbon without a referendum, contrary to the manifesto pledges of all three main parties.
Plus, the new appointments to the Lords are nearly uniformly awful, full of Quango chiefs and human rights commissars.
See Lord Ahmed, for example, who allegedly threatened to have 10,000 Muslims march on Parliament to prevent Geert Wilders from showing his film Fitna (technically an act of treason), and whom no-one at all can eject.
Or Lady Ashton, who has never held elected office in her life, yet now has more power than most ministers.
The Lords may have worked once, but no more. Eject the lot of them, it’s time for a Senate.
Mark Harmstone
I don’t mind Lord Falkener, or many other people sitting in the Upper House, but I didn’t vote for them and I therefore cannot hold them accountable for their legislative blunders by voting otherwise next time around.
Kyle Mulholland
Submit letters to editor@palatinate.org.uk
