Keir Starmer’s Brexit stance – sell out or savvy?

By Freddie Hazlitt

With the prospect of a General Election not being realistic until 2024, it seems odd that electoral strategy has been such an important talking point in the last year. ‘Odd’ is a mild word when describing the political landscape of late. Two prime-ministerial resignations have caused widespread cries for a General Election. It is not surprising that the Opposition has already faced heightened scrutiny regarding policy than would be usual at this point in the electoral cycle. Keir Starmer has faced criticism for relying on dissatisfaction with the Tories rather than on a positive Labour vision for the future. Whilst this has so far had success (latest polls show Labour with a 21-point lead), it is not a sustainable election strategy to count solely on the unpopularity of the opposing party. 

If Starmer has been coy with revealing his economic policy and plans for public-service reform, the same accusation cannot be made about his stance on Brexit. Starmer has already ruled out re-joining the EU, calling it a “red line” for the party. To many pro-European voters this choice may seem baffling. Starmer, alongside 70% of 2017 Labour voters voted Remain in 2016. Current polling suggests the majority favour a return to Europe. A key target demographic for Labour will be Remainer Tory voters, and therefore Starmer has unsurprisingly faced criticisms of his u-turn on Brexit to appeal to the Red Wall.

It is understandable why pro-European voters would feel irked by this stance. Malaise with Brexit is at an all-time high: latest polls show nearly two-thirds of voters support a second referendum, the Bank of England has estimated that Brexit dampened investment by nearly 25% up to 2021, and YouGov surveys have found that only one in three Leave voters think Brexit has been a success. If there was a time to have a conversation about rejoining, it would be now. This U-turn on Brexit is already causing tension: Anas Sarwar, leader of the Scottish Labour Party, has faced extensive calls to support demands to rejoin the EU. Starmer must be careful that he does not take any demographic for granted, for risk of alienation.

This is not a desperate bid to regain Red Wall voters. It is a piece of electoral pragmatism which, if successful, will help the Parliamentary Labour Party avoid the pitfalls of 2019. The 2019 general election was widely seen as being dominated by Brexit, acutely displayed in Johnson’s slogan ‘Get Brexit Done.’ Accordingly, the Conservatives hammered Corbyn on his comparative vagueness regarding his negotiation plan, particularly his pledge to hold a second referendum. This was clearly successful for the Tories: two-thirds of the Conservatives’ vote share was explicitly to deliver Brexit, or in other words, ‘to stop a party I dislike winning’. Labour cannot afford to risk falling into the same traps as 2019.

‘Get Brexit Done’ did not symbolise a great vision for Brexit that Johnson had. It expressed a promise to finally move on from the issue which had dominated the British political scene. Corbyn’s ambiguity could thus be portrayed as regressive and backwards looking. By second guessing the Conservatives and ruling out a return to Europe, Starmer is refusing to let the Conservative party control the agenda for the election.

By defusing the Brexit hand grenade, Labour can bring it into the mixture of reasons for voter dissatisfaction in the government. These reasons are in abundance: cost of living, economic mismanagement, chronic instability, and yes, unresolved Brexit negotiations in Northern Ireland and Europe. Labour will have to do more than just point out these factors: they must still convince the public that they can fix them, and that they are stable enough to govern following the divisions of 2019. This move on Brexit will help Labour to portray themselves as a forward-looking party and remain on the offensive going into the election campaign.

A second referendum is not a realistic option. While the 2016 vote was marred by misinformation and unrealistic campaign pledges, it was still carded as a once-in-a-generation event. The chaos that would be caused by a second referendum would reignite many of the divisions of 2016. Furthermore, it is certainly not clear that Europe would accept the UK back, even if the referendum ended with Remain. Polls have shown that, since 2016, comparable anti-EU movements in other countries have been scuppered by the example of the UK. Even in Italy, the populist nationalist Prime Minister Georgia Meloni has dialled back the rhetoric on the EU, opting instead for more cooperation.

For progress on a trade deal and on the Northern Ireland protocol to happen, temperatures need to be cooled in the public. Rishi Sunak, in actively trying to appeal calmer than his predecessors, has seen improvement in negotiations. If Labour does become the next government, they would (in theory) be able to capitalise on this ‘boring dividend’ even more than Sunak. Not only can they benefit by just ‘not being the Conservatives,’ but they are not beholden to the right wing of the Conservative party, which has handicapped Cameron, May, and Sunak. By taking the electoral focus off Brexit, time in the shadows will hopefully cool the polarisation of recent years about the matter to make realistic progress.

The general election campaign itself will be the ultimate stress-test of Starmer’s remodelled party. Labour have consistently been on the offensive due to the Tories’ poor track record of late. Ruling out a second referendum keeps up this momentum and neuters any attempt to paint Labour as regressive, which defined the 2019 election. For now, Starmer has taken a gamble to avoid the mistakes of 2019. What will define this punt is the extent to which pro-EU Labour voters can temporarily shelve their views on Brexit to get a Labour victory. The reality is that a second referendum still carries too much baggage. If progress is to be made on a trade deal, it is more likely to be achieved by a fresh and more open Labour party than the current Conservative party who have torn themselves apart. Starmer recognises this. Time will tell if his gamble pays off.

Image: Jeremy Corbyn via Flickr