Does the UK need a digital pound?

By Aidan Hague

Bank of England Governor, Andrew Bailey, has raised some scepticism about the need for a new digital pound, in response to announcements from the Economic Secretary to the Treasury (EST), Andrew Griffith, that the finance department intended to launch a public consultation on attributes of a digital pound.

While the EST is keen to stress that “the consultation is going to say this is an if and not a when,” the British government is among many others around the world that are giving serious thought to the possibility of a Central Bank Digital Currency (CBDC).

Research by The Economist has found that 89 countries comprising 90% of the world’s GDP are exploring the possibility of CBDCs. China has already rolled out a digital Yen to several cities, with the EU, Sweden, Canada and Mexico looking soon to follow suit.

For a man who repeatedly stressed his desire “to make the UK a global cryptoassets hub” while in Number 11 and who immediately demanded a cryptocurrency change to his own bill upon acceding Number 10, it is no surprise that Rishi Sunak intends to pursue the concept. What then are these digital currencies and what might we expect to be their implications?

However, those excitedly envisioning the mass shafting of the private banking sector are likely to be disappointed

Conceptually, they have been around in a crude form for some time as “central bank reserves” but the expansion of their rhetorical remit to a currency really indicates how they would be “more widely available to use than just to counterparties” making them another medium of exchange for everyday transactions. One might pay contactless for a bottle of milk just as before but the money would be drawn from an account held with the Central Bank, as opposed to a commercial one.

This is a neat example of one of the most frequently cited reasons for CDBCs and cryptoassets in general: a concern for “financial inclusion” which has seen vastly more press coverage and social media attention in the past few years.

By holding cash assets with a Central Bank, proponents of the concept argue that those mistrusting of traditional consumer banks are likely to be enfranchised by a digital currency. These systems are ideally more efficient and would reduce the percentages of national income that are remitted to providers or payment and settlement services.

Moreover, it appears that the public would be quite content to hold liquid assets outside of the commercial banking sphere with a Canadian study indicating that households could hold between 4% and 55% of their liquid assets in CBDCs, depending on the conditions of use.

However, those excitedly envisioning the mass shafting of the private banking sector are likely to be disappointed. The amount of capital, labour and IT literacy required in order to implement an app-based system for CDBCs makes it almost unimaginable that banks will not get involved in some form.

With these policies in motion […] it is highly likely that Central Banks are due to take more powerful roles on the global stage in future

Add this to the litigative task of providing a robust legal framework for their inclusion in British society and the task is likely to be immense for both the public and private sector. Not that it is necessarily a bad thing, but it may not be the beacon of financial inclusion that some claim it to be.

Some governments do not make any pretences in this regard: the new Bahamian sand dollar can only be held in wallets above £8,000 for those who have passed identity tests. This is first, to act as a deterrent for laundering capital through the currency and, second, to make the currency sufficiently unappealing so as not to expose the economy to crippling bank runs.

Of course, with their newfound supremacy, Central Banks may be able to reinvest deposits back into banks so they can accommodate more diverse portfolios. Though as Goldman Sachs has recently shown us, policy shifts in the financial world can prove to be very vexing and the only alternative would be for these institutions to scale back. With these policies in motion, and louder calls for financial sovereignty, it is highly likely that Central Banks are due to take more powerful roles on the global stage in future.

In a radical world, if cash were to be largely eliminated, regulators could charge interest on digital wallets in order to sharpen transmission of downward monetary policy into the economy, perhaps giving them greater control in times of inflation. Alternatively, if digital currencies were the only store of value, governments could even charge negative rates to stimulate spending during recessions though they would do so at the risk of reputational risk.

As economic libertarians, I suspect that many Conservatives will be happy to argue that the British public should be entitled to these financial objects. However, in a strange turn of fate, it could be Andrew Bailey who finds himself the best off.

Image: Generated by OpenAI’s DALL-E 2