Just Stop Oil protests: stop crying over spilt milk

By Claudia Heard

In recent weeks, not a day has gone by where my Twitter feed hasn’t been strewn with images of orange paint splatters, spilt soup cans, and the ensuing mob of commenters, predictably frustrated by Just Stop Oil’s latest demonstrations. The environmental activism group has engaged in a month of heightened civil resistance throughout October to press the government to halt all new licenses for fossil fuel production. At first glance, it would seem their actions do not reflect this mission — after all, what’s a Van Gogh painting got to do with a protest against non-renewables? Yet, it is becoming increasingly apparent that such bold moves are grabbing them valuable headlines and attention. 

Footage of two Just Stop Oil activists chucking a can of soup at Van Gogh’s Sunflowers at the National Gallery last month, has been viewed via The Guardian’s YouTube channel almost 600,000 times. A video of activists smearing chocolate cake over King Charles’ wax figure at Madame Tussauds garnered similar attention. Some see it as an act of vandalism, others are simply confused. But for those concerned about the artwork, which, was protected by a glass covering, need to wake up to the reality that our planet cannot be so easily salvaged. 

As Van Gogh himself said; ‘…it is not the language of painters but the language of nature which one should listen to, the feeling for the things themselves, for reality is more important than the feeling for pictures.’ Perhaps, then, they should stop moaning about unscathed artwork and turn to the beauty of our planet that is being tarnished every day. It cannot be denied that these endeavours have gotten people talking. Faced with a zombie-like government when it comes to climate change, this is exactly what the movement, and humanity, needs. 

Just Stop Oil activists claim that such striking acts are necessary, given the government’s ignorance, and I support this

Just Stop Oil activists claim that such striking acts are necessary, given the government’s ignorance, and I support this. Constant reminders from scientists are clearly not enough to stir them to action. A recent study by the International Institute of Sustainable Development said there was a “large consensus” across research that “developing any new oil and gas fields is incompatible with limiting warming to 1.5C.” This comes as no surprise given the mounting piles of warnings and scientific reports. 

Yet, the government seems to be plugging their ears. Energy Secretary Jacob Rees-Mogg, for instance, seems to have made light of his government’s own commitments to the Climate Change Act, by instructing his officials to extract ‘every cubic inch of gas,’ while earlier this month, the government made 100 new fossil fuel exploration licenses up for grabs. When credible science is disregarded, Just Stop Oil can hardly be blamed for resorting to more attention-grabbing tactics.

More controversial, understandably, is Just Stop Oil’s roadblocking strategy, which has vexed London commuters. Videos of members of the public forcibly removing protesters from the road have been plastered all over the media, following disruption at several key crossings in London on 29th October. Even Alex de Koning, a spokesperson for Just Stop Oil, has expressed worry that their methods could alienate people from the cause. Surely a movement of this kind needs to take the masses with them? 

We are faced with a government that won’t listen to the science and won’t listen to the masses either

But this ignores the fact that general consensus on the movement’s message, and less disruptive actions, have achieved little. According to a study by Omnisis, 66% of people back non-violent action on climate change, and most are in favour of green policies. Yet this has not proved enough to stop the government ploughing ahead with destructive policy; they have proposed banning solar panels on most farmland, and PM Rishi Sunak wants to lift a ban on fracking where there is local support. Suella Braverman has said on the matter that ‘democracies reach decisions in a civilised manner.’ But there is nothing democratic about the third Prime Minister since the last General Election taking such crucial decisions into his own hands, not to mention Sunak’s initial decision to not attend COP27. 

Clearly, we are faced with a government that won’t listen to the science and won’t listen to the masses either. Those who oppose Just Stop Oil fail to see that their more disruptive actions are necessitated by the government’s idleness. Ministers are more concerned with imposing draconian laws to repress the right to non-violent protest, as seen with the proposal of a new Public Order bill, and denouncing the ‘tofu-eating wokerati,’ rather than making any effort to stop the processes that elicit their action. 

Whichever side of the fence you’re on, Just Stop Oil’s methods have highlighted one thing: unlike the Van Gogh painting, there is no glass covering for the planet. The damage of climate change cannot be so easily wiped away and it is time the government acted accordingly. 

Image: Simon Smith via Flickr