‘It Ends With Us’. Should it end here?
By Charlie Williamson
From airport terminals to the every-growing “Bookstagram”, the distinctive pink flowers that cover Colleen Hoover’s 2016 novel It Ends With Us are sure to make an appearance. The sensitive and emotional themes prevalent in the plot have certainly struck a chord with readers through the central character Lily Bloom.
It recounts her doomed relationship with Ryle Kincaid as she begins to follow in her mother’s footsteps, whose marriage to an abusive husband left Lily with deep psychological fears. Through flashbacks from within old diary entries, we gain an insight into these violent and destructive experiences with her father and the comfort her first love brought her. Ultimately however, Ryle does not live up to the man she had hoped she was marrying, also suffering from past trauma himself, and the book ends with her rekindling her teenage relationship with Atlas.
One notable quote from the book is, “no matter how convinced you are that your life will turn out a certain way, all that certainty can be washed away with a simple change in tide”. And Hoover has undoubtedly influenced the tide of popular literary culture since its release, riding the waves onto every WHSmith shelf and Waterstones table in the past year. Her delicate exploration of domestic violence widens the scope for greater understanding of ‘why women stay’, a challenging and irresolute question that has no singular answer.
Her delicate exploration of domestic violence widens the scope for greater understanding of ‘why women stay’
Lily’s husband Ryle can be kind, funny and sexy but his repeated warning signs, marked by episodes of overpowering anger, help to distance the reader from fully investing in the success of their relationship. He exhibits almost Christian Grey characteristics and this insubstantiality negates from what could have been a more developed morally dubious character. The maturity that Lily showed towards her young love Atlas isn’t convincingly translated to her marriage which is adds to a sense of juvenility and one-dimensionality.
Thematically, the novel satisfies the hype it has received, with its persistent argument that “there are no bad people, just good people who do bad things”. This opens up a conversation surrounding the psyche of someone suffering within a relationship where they still see glimmers of the person they once knew and loved. Hoover demonstrates an understanding of such a convoluted situation, with her experience of her mother who had struggled through the pain of this. Such a personal touch is evident in the portrayal of Lily’s complex relationship with her mother, whilst the flashbacks illustrate the potential for some more very human and very sweet moments.
Yet it must be said that the writing itself is underdeveloped, reminiscent of YA fiction, and inconsistencies (like the 30-year-old neurosurgeon who comes home wearing his hospital scrubs) translate to a frustrating narrative in terms of inauthentic plausibility.
Lily shows an unsettling lack of self-reflection: whilst Ryle is certainly in the wrong, her lack of communication and concealment of obvious lingering feelings for Atlas place the relationship in a fraudulent position, even without the violence. Alyssa, her colleague and best friend (and sister of Ryle), is a whirlwind that, whilst showing a degree of maturity in terms of supporting Lily as opposed to her brother, does not seem to serve much of a literary purpose beyond providing Lily with another acquaintance outside of her male drama.
Ultimately it is the underwhelming ending to the novel that proves most disappointing
Ultimately it is the underwhelming ending to the novel that proves most disappointing. The decision to divorce Ryle is commendable, however the harsh manner in which she does this (whilst he is holding their newborn baby) is almost shocking due to her insistent desire for his patience up until this point. Undoubtedly, the difficulty in leaving him does put into perspective the reality for domestic abuse victims however it still doesn’t seem to fully come to fruition as a narrative.
It fails to leave the reader with that unequivocal flavour of really good literature.
Although the books may still occupy notable spaces on bookstore shelves, its hype is superfluous and I believe Lily’s narrative to be worth no more than an easy, airport read.
Image Credit: Milada Vigerova via Unsplash

