It’s time to scrap the January transfer window

Cabaye who was pursued by PSG in this year's January transfer window
Cabaye, who was pursued by PSG in this year’s January transfer window

By Henry Clare

Money, money, money – it makes the world go round, and, in football terms, its value is far greater than any trophy. Teams have become increasingly like businesses, trading players with one another like chips in an over-elaborate card game.

In the past ten years, money has become a prerequisite to success. Chelsea and Manchester City have both risen from the dreary depths of mid table to the dizzy heights of the top of the Premier League, under the influence of oligarch owners.

With UEFA regularly adding an extra ‘zero’ to the rewards for qualifying for the Champions League, the big clubs will get bigger and the gap between themselves and the smaller teams clubs grow greater.

And the January transfer window does not help; as much as we all love the sight of a flustered Jim White keeping us up to date with players in cars, planes and helicopters on their way to new clubs, having a window midway through the season makes a mockery of the Premier League.

It ensures that the big clubs can never have what we could term ‘a bad season’. If things aren’t going to plan, they can simply throw their excess cash at the best players from lower down the league table. What’s the point of playing nineteen games before the January when the impact of bringing in a new player can help clubs to propel themselves up the table?

The Yohan Cabaye situation is one of the many examples of the failings of the January transfer window. Newcastle have been this season’s surprise package, and looked set to challenge for coveted places in the top six of the Premier League.

“Having a window midway through the season makes a mockery of the Premier League”

Along come Paris-Saint Germain, with their £20 million, and all of a sudden the Toon have lost their best player, and the environment of stability created by Alan Pardew makes way to uncertainty over whether the club will be able to replace him.

In an environment in which the power of managers is dwindling by the second, the January transfer window gives players at lower levels the ideal get-out clause. It’s an irony that the players, who on most occasions are the cause of a team’s poor form, have the chance to jump ship to increase their chances of success (and double their wages).

Often the tactics that players use to manoeuvre their way into another team can be as damaging as their actual departure. Take Peter Odemwingie for example. The Nigerian was involved in one of the most astonishing transfer stories of all time when he drove down the A1 from Birmingham to London under the impression that QPR would open their doors for him. They didn’t, and the backlash from the affair marred what was a superb debut season for Baggies manager Steve Clarke.

Peter Odemwingie's failed transfer was a big hit to West Brom's season
Peter Odemwingie’s failed transfer was a big hit to West Brom’s season

Even if players don’t actually leave their respective clubs, managers can still effectively lose them as any talented player is going to be linked to top clubs. Will a player who has his mind set on a potential move elsewhere be able to match the performances of another who is fully focussed on being successful at their current club?

The Odemwingie saga shows the panicked, hurried fashion with which January transfers are conducted. It’s no surprise that season after season, short term thinking leads to long-term problems.

Midway through a stuttering season, Chelsea lavished a massive £50 million fee on Liverpool’s Fernando Torres, a deal which funded Liverpool’s successful £35 million pursuit of Newcastle’s star man Andy Carroll.

Both players were forced to play in systems that did not suit their playing style, and the careers of Torres and Carroll have stagnated catastrophically since. Between them they have scored 60 goals in three seasons, and each are still priced at over a million pounds per goal.

It’s clear that the January transfer window is a hindrance for both clubs and players –and is nothing more than a safety net for the top clubs. Wouldn’t it be wonderful, if a side like Newcastle – so passionately supported by their local fan base – were to break the stranglehold of the ‘top’ clubs to win the Premier League?

Or if Southampton, with their fleet of home grown players, were to restore everyone’s faith in the game by finishing in the top six, at the expense of the self professed super club Manchester United. But they won’t – the January transfer window just puts the nail in the coffin for this season’s over performing clubs.

Photographs: Beacon Radio & Tricia Kuhn