Israel is not a Nazi state

A  few weeks ago, Ustinov college played host to a Friends of Palestine event. Apart from the very much appreciated music and food, the evening was filled with informative speeches and beautifully read poetry on the subject of the conditions in the occupied territories. But as the evening progressed I felt increasingly uneasy about the frequent comparisons made between Zionism and Nazism, and between the injustices suffered by Palestinians and the Holocaust.

It’s important to understand the background to this anti-Zionist rhetorical device. For the past sixty years, the Holocaust has been involved in the argument for why the state of Israel has a right to exist. There are various rationales for Zionism. One is the (in my view, ridiculous) argument that Jews have a religious claim to the land written about in the Bible. But the main secular rationale starts from the premise that Jews have found themselves throughout history outsiders in predominantly non-Jewish countries, and as such have been subject to intolerable anti-Semitism. Israel, according to this argument, exists in order to be the one country where Jews will always be welcome and safe. Against this argument, opponents of Zionism have typically said that there is no reason why Jews should inevitably feel ostracised or threatened in ‘non-Jewish’ countries. I’m inclined towards this view, not least on the grounds that Jews in, say, America are today considerably safer than Jews in Israel. On this point of contention, however, the Holocaust enters the discussion. It simply became more difficult to sustain such optimism following the news that an ostensibly civilised European country had carried out the mass-murder of Jews.

The hurt and anger felt by so many Palestinians about their treatment as a result of the Zionist project, therefore, understandably results in a certain suspicion about the Holocaust. Conditions of racial segregation breed distrust and paranoia (witness the unfortunate theory that the CIA invented HIV as a weapon against black people) so it is easy enough to see why Palestinians might question the facts about the Holocaust, and especially its status as a uniquely evil and horrific crime. It doesn’t help to assuage conspiracy theorists that there are laws in some European countries against raising these doubts in public (though, of course, if the Holocaust really had been the concoction of a conspiracy, setting up such laws would surely not have been a very slick way of suppressing enquiry).

I should stress that Holocaust denial was not expressed by anyone at the Friends of Palestine event.

However, the vocabulary of the Holocaust – concentration camps, gassing and such like – was part of the way that the situation of Palestinians was provocatively described by some of the speakers. Why use this language and make this comparison? It doesn’t much help us to understand the conditions of people living in Gaza, but it does encourage us to wonder whether, in private, anti-Semitism is part of the worldview of those who talk in this way.

Anti-Semitism is historically a paranoiac response to conditions that developed in Christendom, in which Jewish minorities – considered Christ-killers by some of their more literal-minded neighbours – lived on the edges of respectable society, were barred from the professions, and as a result tended to make their living through trade. Anti-Semitism has expressed a working class resentment of those who succeed financially and an aristocratic resentment of the nouveau riche. It has been a theme of populism on the left and the right of the political spectrum.

The phenomenon of anti-Semitism in the Muslim world has much less historical basis than that in Christian countries, but it has evidently become a significant distorting factor in the political discourse that has developed since 9/11. To give a concrete example, Inayat Bunglawala of the Muslim Council of Britain, a regular on the Guardian’s ‘Comment is Free’ website, once wrote in a magazine called ‘Trends’ that, “The chairman of Carlton Communications is Michael Green of the Tribe of Judah. He has joined an elite club whose members include fellow Jews Michael Grade and Alan Yentob… [They are] close friends… so that’s what they mean by a ‘free media’.” Thoughts like these – hinting at a vast Jewish conspiracy manipulating the masses by faking Islamist terrorist attacks to generate support for wars in the Middle East – seemed to have gained currency among certain circles of opinion.

The electoral success of Hamas in Palestine a few years ago does not suggest an entirely healthy political culture, either. I don’t mean this to sound severely judgemental. Who would expect health in such circumstances? But it is clear that Hamas represents the more extreme, theocratic, violent and anti-Semitic end of the spectrum of resistance. Ironically, the organisation is a by-product of Israel’s cynical divide-and-rule strategy of investing money in Islamic fundamentalism as a counter to secular Palestinian nationalism. The founding principles of Hamas eschew compromise and demand an Islamic state from the Jordan to the Mediterranean. No doubt there were other reasons for its electoral success, but this doesn’t mean we should not be disconcerted by the victory of an organisation whose former leader, Abdel Aziz Rantissi (assassinated by the Israelis in 2004), once wrote in a Hamas publication: “Many thinkers and historians have exposed the lies of the Zionists, thus becoming a target of Zionist persecution. Some have been assassinated, some arrested, and some are prevented from making a living.”

Politics of this kind is no friend of Palestine. If I were trying to engage people in the cause, I’d do my best to firmly distance my rhetoric from that of anti-Semites. A pacific and equitable solution is possible if hostile mindsets are set aside on both sides. Comparisons between Israel and the Third Reich are bad history, bad politics and bad taste. I suppose it’s not really my business, but the cause seems to me too important to be associated with demagoguery.