Has Darwinian evolution stopped?

The speciation of humans occurred round about 200,000 years ago; a mere thumbprint on the window of a skyscraper in terms of time, and for over 95% of our existence, we survived on hunting and gathering. Around 10,000 years ago, with the advent of farming in the Near East, people became much more sedentary, soon followed by what is deemed civilisation. Now, this is an almost offensive account of the past 10,000 years, but I want to talk about the future, not the past.

Through that 200,000 year period and all the millions of years before, natural selection has driven evolution, and all the species we see today are the result of this. Contrary to many people’s beliefs, we did not evolve from chimpanzees and gorillas, but rather evolved with them, and we continue to do so, or dowe?

The other week, noted geneticist Professor Steve Jones, gave a speech at University College London in which he postulated that natural human evolution has stopped. A scary thought. Has the human race reached such an evolutionary endpoint?

There is, in the first world at least, an argument to be made for Professor Jones’ thoughts. Over the past decade or so, the populations of Western Europe, Scandinavia and Japan have started to level out and perhaps even decrease, entering the dubbed fifth stage of the Demographic Transition Model. If the birth rate is low, i.e. people are having fewer children, there is less chance of mutation and the selection of those mutations. Meaning that, essentially, humans may enter a status-quo as far as natural selection goes.

Sexual selection will continue to drive our evolution, of course. Certain traits in fashion will continue which dictate what people find attractive – bodily hair; the need for glasses, baldness etc may be selected either for or against. But natural selection will decrease. This is partly down to the benefits of clinical medicine and the fact that infant mortality is so very low (in Darwin’s day, half the children died – raw material for natural selection). Combine this low infant mortality rate with a decreasing birth rate, and we see the chances for genetic mutation, the criterion for natural selection, decrease.

We cannot definitely say that natural selection has actually stopped; it doesn’t just occur in a period of a few decades, but over many generations. However, with what is understood about the process of natural selection, it is reasonable to assume that in the future, if we continue the way we are going, natural selection may well come to an end.

It appears then that we now control, or at least affect, every aspect of our environment. This is certainly going to be true of genetics, according to Princeton geneticist Professor Lee Silver, who is speculating that, in the near future, we will be able to do amazing things with genes. The ideas born of science fiction are rapidly becoming scientific fact.

As we all know, it has been possible for years now to create life in a test-tube. In the near future, instead of just being able to help those unable to conceive, there will be help to eradicate hereditary disease or illness. This will actively inhibit aspects of natural selection. As the number of people with these diseases falls, everybody’s healthy, everybody’s desirable and everybody lives.

As brilliant an idea as this is, it opens the gates to an explosively precarious moral dilemma – where will it stop? Silver argues that if trivial phenotypes such as eye colour can be selected artificially, they will be. Although this experimentation is illegal in humans, it is legal in animals. Observations were made on such an experiment with a mouse, which was given the growth hormone of a rat; its offspring were seen to present hyper-growth characteristics.

Silver argues that legality will not be an issue if there is a market. Another scary thought. If the rich can afford to choose whether or not their children are dark-haired and blue eyed, tall, slim, olive-skinned, smart and healthy, why wouldn’t they? Surreal enough for you yet? Well, it may just get worse. Normally, one’s choice of genes is limited to the mother and the father. It is anticipated that certain popular traits will be stored en masse, where one could select traits for their offspring from a list: a genetic hypermarket.

If we take this idea to the extreme, we may see the gap between rich and poor widening, even into different species. With a set of genetically superior people, unable to mate with those who could not afford the treatment. You may think this is just speculation, but most of the science is possible.

It’s just a matter of time before it is perfected and reproduced on an industrial scale. I fear what we’re seeing now is just the tip of the iceberg.