Is the present day the worst time in recent history to be a student?
With most current Durham students having had their studies set against the background of the Covid-19 pandemic, strikes and other major events, Palatinate Comment asked two contributors to argue which period in history they believe was the worst time to be a student.
“The 2008 cohort of graduates did not have the pleasure and privilege of preparation”
By Jemima Myles
Many current students are yet to experience a term at university unaffected by misfortuneſ such as world conflict, strikes, and a pandemic. However, whether or not now is the worst time to be a student may be a pointless debate. After all, students have been affected by various hardships for as long as universities have existed, and will continue to complain about the difficulties impacting them for as long as the said difficulties prevail.
There have incredibly tense times for students in recent history, in geo and socio-political terms, which complicated student life in ways unimaginable to us presently. For example, students were driven to rioting in the 1960s against old-fashioned course structures and inadequate facilities; and more widely, oppression, racism and discrimination in the establishment.
More recently, students in 2010 protested against planned spending cuts to further education, and an increased cap to tuition fees.
We live in an age where our experiences of university could continue in many ways
Certainly, the weight of the world feels against students nowadays. Our experiences have been characterised by a doubtlessly decreased quality of education and social life due to the pandemic, on top of strikes, as well as the current immense anxiety of major conflict. We can at least appreciate, however, that we live in an age where our experiences of university could continue in many ways through the pandemic (often albeit online, and to a fairly limited extent) and not be halted in their entirety.
The real difficulty seems to be, in the pandemic years and post-pandemic years to come, that we do not necessarily even attend university with the promise of the dream graduate job that makes it all worthwhile in the end. This is a sentiment eerily familiar to that of young graduates when the financial crisis shocked the world in 2008.
Unemployment among young graduates in the U.K. rose from 11.1% in December 2008 to 14% in December 2009, and all the while salaries were decreasing. In 2020, the job market almost returned to exactly that of its depraved state in 2008. The unemployment rate for young graduates rose up to 13.6%, a close second to the year after the financial crisis. Arguably, by the time Covid-19 struck the world, the job market for graduates had not yet returned to a healthier state than pre-crash by any means. As ever, though, employment remained considerably more friendly to graduates than non-graduates; for young non-graduates unemployment sat notably more unflatteringly at 28.7%.
The tragic impact the pandemic had on these aspects of university have been quite incessantly discussed
What comes after university is certainly a driving motivator for many of us in becoming students in the first place, but our years of academic enrichment are not just a means to an end. The extracurricular and social sides to university are just as important, if not more so, to substantial numbers of students.
The tragic impact the pandemic had on these aspects of university have been quite incessantly discussed. Nonetheless, now is the time to make up for the moments impacted by misfortunate circumstances throughout our student life.
Although it is definitely a suboptimal time to be a student, and probably an even worse time to be a graduate, at least we now know (to an extent) what to expect. The 2008 cohort of graduates did not have the pleasure and privilege of preparation. Moreover, the current generation of university-aspiring adolescents may not have the opportunity to even attempt to achieve their ambitions, thanks to new requirements set to be introduced by the Department for Education.
There may never be a perfect time to be a student
University fees have almost tripled in past 13 years; in 2009, fees were capped at £3,225 per year to take account of inflation after the crash. With this, the burden of student loan debt has therefore more than quadrupled in England, from 2008 to 2020; these statistics speak for themselves.
Despite current prospects for graduates being rather bleak, and many facets of university life in the past few years having been adversely affected, being a student is still worthwhile. As time goes on, the current misfortunes affecting student life will hopefully dissipate. It is more probable, however, that they will change and evolve, much as they have done so in the past.
There may never be a perfect time to be a student, only ebbs and flows in the hardships affecting student life.
Horrible histories: why past students had it worse
By Hadrian Lam
The pandemic has certainly caused great disruptions to our daily lives as students. It radically changed the lives of millions of people across the globe. Together with the saddening Russian invasion of Ukraine, and the continuation of academic staff strikes with questionable effectiveness, students’ studies have been greatly affected. As a result of the combination of these events, the current period of time is sometimes compared to the most destructive period in modern history – World War II.
Most of us who have experienced the pandemic did not live through WWII. If one looks into university life during WWII in greater detail, it will become clear that life as a student during WWII was substantially more difficult.
Firstly, the mortality rate during WWII was significantly higher than that in the modern-day UK. Under the imposition of the The National Service (Armed Forces) Act, all males aged between 18 to 41, except for the unfit and those who were in key industries (studying was not one if you were wondering), were legally required to be conscripted.
Over the course of the war’s six dreadful years, 7.8% of the British army (383,000 out of the 4,000,000) lost their lives, many of which were young men of university age. Especially during a time when most of the student population were male, much of the student population would have been conscripted to fight, with a very real chance of dying.
Much of the student population would have been conscripted to fight
Humanities students like myself would likely be conscripted first and possibly die first. Being a science student was in some ways better, as you could be recruited by the government to conduct military experimentations and research, but this would take you away from your studies.
You would not have been safe as a civilian either as prior to the Battle of Britain, you would have been in constant fear of being bombed by the Luftwaffe (mainly those in the south-east). More than 70,000 civilians died during WWII.
On the other hand, the death rate of Covid-19 in the UK is currently only 0.86%, and young people such as students have a much lesser chance to be seriously ill from Covid-19. According to my personal experience, you would only have to endure the symptoms for a day or two before being good to go.
Secondly, there was no ‘silver bullet’ to end WWII. Casualties would only cease when one side surrenders, leading to the end of the war. Even with the invention of the atomic bombs that stopped the Japanese, casualties were simultaneous with the dropping of the bombs and its consequential aftermath. It was only due to the surrender of the Axis powers in 1945, after six long years, that conscripts were able to return to normal lives and stop having to sacrifice their lives.
During the pandemic, students could easily attend lectures and seminars through Zoom
During the pandemic, however, it took only one year for pharmaceutical companies across the world to come up with a number of Covid-19 vaccines for us to adapt and be able to co-exist with the virus. Even if the pandemic lasts for years, we would possibly not have to fear for our lives, as long as we get vaccinated.
Lastly, the pandemic occurred in a time when our lives are much more flexible due to advancement of communication technology. During WWII, UCL had to physically move to Aberystwyth due to the Blitz, in order to continue to provide education.
During the pandemic, when physical contact was prohibited, students could easily attend lectures and seminars through Zoom or Teams. Similarly, Durham RAF conscripts had to take military training at University College while undertaking their academic degrees in their remaining time, without resources such as online recordings or Powerpoints that we possess during the pandemic.
The situation was even more difficult for international students during WWII as it would have taken them months to travel back to where they came from.
Chinese Egyptologist Xia Nai, who was completing his Egyptology doctorate degree at UCL at the time, was unable to defend his doctoral thesis due to being needed back in his country. If this were to happen in the modern day, Dr Xia could probably have defended his thesis without much delay through video conferences. It was, therefore, logistically much more difficult for students to study during WWII compared to studying during the pandemic.
Image: Heather Mount via Unsplash

