Fall of FTX: are calls for crypto regulation misplaced?
By Hadrian Lam
Like dominos, crypto giants Terraform Labs, Three Arrows Capital, Celsius, etc., are going down one after another, and this time, it’s FTX. The former third largest centralized cryptocurrency exchange (CEX) just filed for bankruptcy and according to a Bloomberg report, the exchange had almost $9 billion in liabilities and $9.5 billion in assets. The exchange was endorsed by the likes of Tom Brady and Steph Curry, even the Miami Heat’s stadium is named after the exchange.
Prior to his downfall, the founder of the exchange, ex-CEO Sam Bankman-Fried, was even featured on Forbes 400 and was heralded as the next Warren Buffet by Fortune Magazine. The collapse could be said to have directly caused the price of major cryptocurrencies Bitcoin and Ethereum to plunder by more than 20%.
So, what went wrong? In short, FTX turned out to be run by a group of friends who had little integrity and lacked risk management skills, and depended too heavily on their own FTT token which had no intrinsic value. Alameda Research, a trading firm that is also owned by Bankman-Fried, discreetly used FTX customer funds to finance their operations.
So, a news article about how Alameda Research has been using FTX customer funds as collateral, and lost a lot of money due to the recent economic downturn and poor trading decisions, FTX in turn was not able to recall their loans.
Foreseeing the inevitable catastrophe and seeing the opportunity to take down one of its largest competitors, leading crypto exchange Binance decided to liquidate all of its holding of FTT tokens, worth around $2.1 billion. While this might simply be a retaliation against Bankman-Fried for Binance CEO Changpeng Zhao (though Binance claimed it as a post-exit risk management strategy), the liquidation led to a bank run of $451 million worth of FTT tokens on FTX. The price of FTT plummeted by 94%, from around $25 to the current $1.50. This also meant that there was no way out for Alameda Research to liquidate their assets.
I propose that there should be no regulation. Hear me out
More recently, there has been a reported ‘hack’ on FTX of tokens worth $400 million following the exchange’s bankruptcy while the exchange had actually prepared to release tokens worth around $380 million in batches over the coming years. While this could be coincidental, Alameda Research have had always accessed FTX funds through a backdoor that was installed by, you guessed it, Bankman-Fried.
So was this actually a so-called ‘hack’ as described by Bankman-Fried, who’s currently under ‘police supervision’ in his luxurious mansion in the Bahamas? It is possible that the ‘hack’ was an inside job using the same backdoor that Alameda Research has always been using. At the point of writing this article, the ‘hacker’ converted the stolen funds to ETH and has just dumped around 25,000 ETH which is worth around $30 million, causing the price of ETH to drop by 4%.
Call for regulation?
The price for the unregulated nature of the crypto industry is showcased by the success of the FTX Ponzi: the FTX executives got richer than ever, FTX customers lost all of their deposits, plummeting prices of major cryptocurrencies, and people became more sceptical about crypto than ever. Furthermore, crypto is often perceived to be ‘untraceable’ which makes it perfect for money laundering and resulted in many calling for more regulation in the industry. However, this is simply not true and I propose that there should be no regulation. Hear me out.
First of all, crypto is traceable. Transactions made on decentralized exchanges (DEX) could be tracked using tools like Etherscan. The purpose of blockchains and cryptocurrencies is to enable a decentralized ecosystem that the people would have sole ownership of their money without being ripped off by regulations (taxes) and centralized institutions (banks).
The problem that we currently have as in the case of FTX is that there are not enough regulations for a centralized institution. Imagine if neither the FCA nor the SEC existed in the real world to regulate the centralized institutions aka banks, brokers, investment funds, etc., do you think any of them would ‘play fair’?
Ever since crypto’s conception, it has always been said that ‘not your wallet, not your tokens’ which many people either don’t understand or just decide to ignore. Depositing your money on a CEX like FTX is basically depositing money into the exchange’s wallet, a custodian wallet, similar to that depositing at a bank, a centralized entity, and if there’s a bank run, it’s over.
Not only did FTX wrongfully loan customer funds from its right hand to its left, but it also apparently had no accounting work nor due diligence work done for its operations, which would definitely have raised many flags had it been a centralized institution in traditional finance. Given that FTX was a CEX, I totally agree there should have been regulations, but centralization is exactly what crypto is not about or what it should not be. Even Alamanda Research clearly knew about this as they actually cleared their debts on the DEX Abracadabra and chose not to on FTX as records on the platform were not public.
Regulations are often imposed because of the financial benefits that they will bring and they often get manipulated by governments and big institutions for their own interests
Furthermore, are regulations actually in place in the interest of retail customers? Or have regulations always been used as a tool to protect the interests of the elites and those in power, which have the side effects of occasionally protecting the retail customer?
Regulations are often imposed because of the financial benefits that they will bring and they often get manipulated by governments and big institutions for their own interests. Examples include Liz Truss’s mini-budget to lift banker bonuses at a time when the wider population is suffering from high costs of living and the Zero-Covid policy in China to protect the Chinese government’s integrity and prevent the outflow of cash. Even with the current financial regulations that we have, many are still able to bypass such regulations through loopholes by means of political lobbying or overseas shell companies. And that is why DEX is the only way to go forward because CEX are inherently flawed and the power of regulations is largely limited.
For cryptocurrencies to shake off their negative image and strive as a currency that is widely recognized, CEXs should not exist because they directly contradict the fundamental value of decentralization of blockchain technology. CEXs are products of people trying to imitate traditional financial practices in the unorthodox field of crypto and leveraging the profitability of crypto due to its unregulated nature. Hence, regulations are necessary for centralized institutions because greed is inherent in human nature.
For those who then asks ‘how should we avoid yield farming scams or avoid investing in worthless tokens’, it must be realized that when you have total control of your own assets, you are also responsible for your own risk management. “Your wallet, your money” which means that you’ll have to conduct all the due diligence by yourself before investing in anything and that is common sense. The mindset of having a layer of protection by a third party must be “decentralized” should one really wants involve oneself in the crypto ecosystem. There’s always the option of traditional finance if ones thinks that crypto is too risky.
Image: Mariia Shalabaieva via Unsplash

