Is Politics just for the Posh?

by Alexander Bond

Andrew Neil’s recent documentary “Posh and Posher: Why Public School Boys Run Britain?”  has pushed our political culture firmly into the spotlight, by asking why our politicians are plucked from such a small elite and why, as Peter Mandelson states, politics is getting “posher and narrower”. Indeed the days of the meritocracy that Neil himself claims to represent now appear to be gone, with an ever-increasing emphasis being placed on where one has come from. With 75 per cent of the cabinet holding millionaire status, this becomes all the more damning. It is not my interest to wage class warfare but one must not blindly deny the existence of the chasm that currently exists between the rich and poor, a gap created by Labour and one being forced further apart by the Coalition, a gap that is hindering the existence of a more representative politics.

It is a difficult point to ignore. The elites are finding their way to the top while the working man is being affected by a reality that bears little resemblance to those who represent them. Neil asks the question of whether MPs have the moral authority to carry out deficit reduction when it seems they are shielded from its impact. It prompts the perennial line given by politicians of “in my constituency surgery”, which now appears to be an artificial layer that erodes at the veneer of our politicians being of ‘the people’, and is something that has tarnished Labour, the working-class party.

It is true to argue that the Government of our country should be filled with the most intellectually-capable individuals. The ability to have a strong education should never hinder anyone, but nor should a less favourable education. With twenty Old Etonians in Parliament does it mean that is it more of an advantage to attend public schools? This is a point which is affirmed by Lord Hurd, who asserts that at Eton “doors were open to you that were closed to others”. However, intellect is just one facet of public service. Indeed, it does not necessarily entail good government or being attuned to the needs of your constituency. As we have seen in the expenses scandal, our politicians aspire for power and exploit it for greed, not a duty or mandate to govern; their interest is not of the people but themselves.

The opportunities for the working man to rise into Parliament still exist, but the reality of these being replaced with tangible results is becoming more fleeting. Neil correctly highlights the issue of comprehensive and public school pupils not being on a level playing field when they leave school, thus highlighting the Westminster taboo of the 11+ and the end of grammar schools.  Tony Parsons in the documentary claims that this is the only solution to this problem. He acknowledges that our public schools should be the best, but this should not hinder state school pupils from having equal opportunities. The networking and contacts achieved at public school and Oxbridge educations should not close the door in the faces of those who do not receive such privileges. Neil argues astutely that the issue lays firmly in our education system, which holds a crucial role in the social mobility of our students to the higher echelons of power and society.

I hold an incessant hope that we see a resurgence in the Alan Johnson-type politician, or even the Gordon Brown-like figure that rises to the very top. However, as long as being a member of parliament is no longer a role to aspire to with the hope of instigating change, but sustaining an elite dominance, this is not a situation that will remedy itself overnight. It appears clear to me that in the austerity culture and deficit spiel which we are now subject to, the credibility of our politicians is diminishing and their claims to have some sort of connection with ‘the people’ is looking increasingly facile. It might take a noticeable dent to the voting figures to cause this detachment to manifest itself, to truly emphasise just how impenetrable the Westminster bubble has become.