Debts, downgrades and deadlocks in USA
Will it or won’t it happen? The biggest question on Wall Street and Capitol Hill was finally answered as Standard and Poor’s downgraded America’s credit rating to a mere AA+ joining countries like New Zealand and Belgium.
What appears to be a simple switch of an ‘A’ for a ‘+’ carries important implications in determining the pattern of the markets. It is this rating which indicates how likely debt is going to be repaid back to its lenders. This change could dramatically alter the course of borrowing for the American economy. A change to AA+ could lead to greater demands for debts to be returned due to the increase in the risk of the investment. This downgrade is not at all palatable to US debt-holders, least of all China.
Pervasive embarrassment for Obama and his Administration is the immediate impact as their attempts to stimulate the economy seem to be flaccid at best. The downgrade followed after warnings from Standard and Poor’s that America needed desperately to cut its deficit by $4 trillion over ten years. However, only $2.1 trillion was agreed by Congress, which S&P called “modest savings.” These plans also see the federal debt ceiling raise by $2.4 tn from $14.3 tn over the next decade. However, the agency pulled no punches in raising questions over the ‘effectiveness, stability, and predictability of American policymaking and political institutions’ which ‘have weakened at a time of ongoing fiscal and economic challenges.’ John Chambers, head of sovereign ratings for S&P, was one of the many individuals to affirm the existence of no credible plan and a failing political system as the logical consequence of the decision.
Obama’s Administration did not take too well to the decision raising questions of the credibility of Standard and Poor’s figures. The Treasury stated that calculations were out by around $2 tn. This reinforces many of those who believe that countries should rely on their own credit rating estimates rather than from external organisations that some believe has created a fractious relationship between Europe and America in this time of economic turmoil.
However, optimism was to be found amongst investors who correctly argue that America is still appealing for investment. This does appear to be the most reasonable line of response and to ignore the potentially facile claims over the attractiveness of America’s investment potential. Paradoxically, the downgrade of the debt was actually beneficial to America as their government debt is seen as a ‘safe haven’ asset by investors. Although it does expose how much America’s polarised political system brings the country’s fate onto a knife edge as many believed America would default on some of its debts.
What this downgrade represents is further polarisation for America. From the Republicans, we have accusations of decadent over-spending. From the Democrats, we have accusations of political sabotage. There appears to be no middle ground and therefore no solution to this crisis. Perhaps the situation is slightly more complex in Britain, but there is a clear contrast. To repeat the maxim that serves as the justification for the coalition the Liberal Democrats and the Conservatives have put aside party differences for the national interest. However, the possibility of this occurring in America is extremely slender. It is obvious that party interest is becoming before national interest. To prove the point, both sides accused it of being a “tea party downgrade” by former presidential candidate John Kerry and “Obama’s downgrade” by Republican activists.
The more ominous result of the downgrade is that China has now begun to express disquiet over America’s situation. As the largest holder of US debt, they lambasted the US Government and made an audacious attempt to question whether the US dollar should remain as the global currency reserve. On the other hand, South Korea was far more muted in their response, naturally appealing for market certainty. Australian Prime Minister Julia Gillard tried a similar approach arguing that only one of the three credit rating agencies have been forced to downgrade, but this seems largely irrelevant due to the indefinite blow to the credibility of America’s ability to pay its debts.
It seems clear that the situation for America is going to get far worse before it gets better. With unemployment sitting at 9.1%, a huge deficit and no workable long-term solution in sight, the double-dip recession looms for the America. With S&P claiming that there is a 1 in 3 chance of America’s credit rating being downgraded again, it would be no surprise that the current global economic turbulence is unlikely to be remedied soon.

