Is Gareth Southgate still the one?

By Jonny Tiplady and Ben Bayly

In this piece, two of Palatinate Sport’s finest contributors battle it out in a war of words over the now-decided fate of Gareth Southgate’s tenure as England manager. Following the recent World Cup quarter-final defeat to France, this one stands as a hot topic for the Three Lions faithful. Here are their views:

Why Southgate should leave

By Jonny Tiplady

I will start this with a disclaimer that contradicts my argument somewhat; I actually quite like Gareth Southgate. He has been a terrific manager who has united a squad so fractured after their Euro 2016 shortcomings. He has brought the side closer to success than I have ever experienced in my lifetime. Statistically, one could argue that he has even been England’s most successful manager since Sir Alf Ramsay. Why, then, do I think he should leave?

Being a nice man can only get you so far, in football particularly and especially in international management. When the squad spends such little time together each year, there is an increased pressure on each international break and tournament for results.

On the face of it, you could argue results are something that Southgate has delivered; a European Championship final in 2021 and a World Cup quarter-final and semi-final in 2022 and 2018 respectively were much better than anything England fans had seen in decades.

Yet, their latest defeat against France leaves me feeling like this is a squad with such rich potential, but under a manager who has taken them as far as he can. England’s record over the last four years has earned the team a label as ‘nearly men’. Ours is a young, hungry squad, who will yet reach their peak before the next World Cup.

However, this new ‘golden generation’ cannot be remembered for always coming up short. We need only look at the example of Belgium squads in recent years – a huge wealth of talent needs the right manager at the helm to make the most of it. These exciting talents need someone who can allow them to flourish, not one who shackles them.

International management boils down to tactics, and Southgate is many things, but a master tactician is not one of them. He has proven indecisive in key games in the past and lacks the proactivity to ever make England a fearsome side.

These exciting talents need someone who can allow them to flourish, not one who shackles them

England had their quarter-final in the palm of their hands against France; we went down to an early goal, yet our performance warranted a result against the world champions. All we lacked was that killer instinct against the French, but that is something that can and should be instilled by the manager.

The game against Italy last year was a different tale. England took an early lead against their opponents, but then were far too passive for the remainder of the game, inviting pressure and, eventually, conceding a goal. The common theme of both these instances was inaction.

Southgate is slow to introduce players who are known to influence games when he needs to. Jack Grealish, an ideal player in the latter stages of a game, who can draw fouls and create opportunities from set pieces, was given just two minutes of extra time against France.

One of Southgate’s main criticisms has been his steadfast loyalty to certain members of the squad, and while faith in your players is never a bad thing, it should never come at the expense of necessary tactical changes.

This is why I believe it is imperative that we act now, and not risk being victims of this passivity yet again. Replacing Southgate now will give his successor enough time before Euro 2024 to make his mark on this England side. No matter our level of success, he has always had his detractors.

By taking action now and replacing him, the squad can build trust over a sustained period under his successor, with a realistic hope of success in North America in 2026. Gareth Southgate, you have brought us some wonderful memories, and for that I thank you, but your journey has run its course.

Why Southgate should stay

By Ben Bayly

What could have been. But for a missed penalty, poor refereeing, and two goals against the run of play, England could have been facing Morocco for a place in the World Cup final. Agonising near misses are not new under the Gareth Southgate regime. The semi-final run in 2018 saw Croatia come from behind, while England were arguably the better side in the 2020 Euros final, only to lose on penalties.

However, let’s not forget such near misses are a stark improvement from the pre-Southgate era. It was only in 2016 when England crumbled to defeat against Iceland, and the Sam Allardyce debacle saw the England team become the laughing stock of international football.

Performances and the feeling around the team have improved remarkably since. A sense of optimism and togetherness has replaced the negativity that once surrounded English football.

The players have also embraced a sense of integrity installed by Southgate. They have duly become deserving of their role model status, using their position as a force for good. As a result, it is impossible not to like Southgate’s team.

No one knows the ins and outs of English football like him

Southgate has been criticised for his defensive style of play, with pundits and fans pointing to the exclusion of players such as Leicester City’s James Maddison. However, tournament football is not won by beautiful football but by pragmatism.

Just look at France and Argentina. Neither are particularly easy on the eye, relying instead on solidity and moments of individual brilliance. In comparison, Spain’s tiki-taka football crashed out at the Round of 16 again.

Our most successful manager since Sir Alf Ramsey, Southgate, knows best. With ten years in the FA and even longer as part of the England set-up, no one knows the ins and outs of English football like him.

He is, therefore, best placed to capitalise upon the template he has so brilliantly laid and lead England to the head of the ‘top table’ of international football. With just 18 months to go until Euro 2024, he won’t have long to wait. There he can show he is still the one.

Image: John Ray via Flickr