Is Durham the victim of a ‘Tescopoly’?
Palatinate investigates the impact of Tesco on local shops in Durham, asking whether a small shopkeeper can offer better value than the big supermarkets
by Pippa Wilkinson
Have you been to Tesco this week? If you live out then the answer is almost certainly yes. It is a frequently cited fact that ÂŁ1 out of every 7 spent in the UK is spent in Tesco, and whether or not this is true, their turnover in 2010 was ÂŁ62,500,000,000. And I have put the correct number of zeros.
There are four Tesco stores in the Durham area, more than any other supermarket, all contributing to their incredible profits. To judge by the six deep queues in the Tesco on Market Square today, a lot of us students must be shopping there, but meanwhile, other local shops are losing out.
Some shop owners say the effect of the recently opened Tesco Metro is minimal, although they were affected when it first opened, and see the ongoing building work in Market Square as a bigger factor in any loss of business.
However, others do believe that the store has had an adverse effect on trade in the city centre. Mother Earth Quality Wholefoods, which has experienced a fall in sales, commented that customers drop in after going to Tesco to look for specialist foods not available there, whereas once they might have done the bulk of their shopping at the Indoor Market. They added that the new store is changing Durham as a whole, in particular those super cheap drinks deals that we students enjoy so much. Tesco responded saying that they encouraged all their customers to drink responsibly, and that there are offers on many different products.
Robinson’s Fruit and Veg were more outspoken, claiming that Tesco was “sucking up the lifeblood in our town.” They criticised their competitive pricing practices on key products like bananas as they force smaller shops, who are unable to buy in bulk and sell cheap, to deplete their stocks. Many end up going out of business. In turn, this reduces the choice of retailers in the city centre and allows Tesco to bring their prices up.
Tesco on the other hand, argue that Durham is still a “vibrant city” with “great shops in the city centre.” They also stated that they draw more customers to the area, and that nearby shops can thrive if they offer what customers want. Oddbins backed up this view, saying that although they were nervous when the Tesco Metro opened, their business is up as customers have returned for quality, specialist knowledge and friendly service.
The anti-supermarket Tescopoly campaign however, paints a different picture, saying that, “Small independent stores and suppliers, and ultimately consumers, are paying a direct price in the face of unfair competition.”
Price Comparison:
Product Freshly Baked Bread Mature Cheddar Potatoes Carrots Tesco 80p £6.96/kg on offer at 2 250g packs for £3 £1.50 for 2.5kg On offer at £1 for 1.2kg Local Shop £1 (Akins Family Baker) £14/kg (Teesdale Game and Poultry) 89p for 2kg (Robinson’s) 80p/kg (Robinson’s)
Another comment from a shopkeeper was that Tesco’s long open hours, which previous supermarkets in the Gates Centre like Waitrose and Safeway didn’t have, give them a significant advantage,
All the local traders agreed that it was noticeable how many students shop at Tesco. So why do we chose Tesco? Students interviewed cited convenience and speed as their main reasons for shopping there, saying that even if products were cheaper elsewhere, the location and range at Tesco were more important. A Josephine Butler student commented that the distance between their college and the city centre, and the lack of a direct bus, made Tesco delivery the only viable option for them, even though she would rather shop in other places.
The mini price comparison carried out shows a mixed performance from Tesco pricewise. Although bread is cheaper, other independent shops sell vegetables at better prices, and are even still cheaper than in Tesco when they are on offer. Cheese was the only product that was much, much cheaper in Tesco. However, quality wasn’t taken into account, and Teesdale Game and Poultry in the Indoor Market present themselves as sellers of gourmet food.
Local shops are making an effort to attract students back, with a 10% discount and special offers through their Facebook page at Robinson’s. There is also a card scheme called Tagpassiton. However, take up has been poor and the initial £5 cost of the card, which gives discounts at a number of independent shops and restaurants, has put many potential users off.
Independent shops are still here in Durham, but it could be only a matter of time before they disappear, like the Italian wine merchant in the Market. They will need to adapt and fight in a serious way if they are going to survive the challenge of the supermarkets.

