Are the Middle East uprisings ‘Twitter revolutions’?
Egypt’s uprising has been called the Facebook Revolution and the Twitter Revolution, and tweets were a substantial part of the coverage on websites such as BBC News and the Guardian. In Libya right now, tweets and videos from mobile phones are also playing an important role in the coverage. But how much is social media really changing the course of the North African and Middle Eastern uprisings?
The importance of the Al-Jazeera coverage of the Tunisian uprising, with its reliance on the views of Tunisians themselves, via Facebook, Twitter and email, cannot be stressed enough. All around the Arab world, ordinary people watched the news channel on satellite. They watched a people take action and succeed, and realised that they could do the same.
In Egypt, on the first crucial days of protest, the regime switched off the internet and mobile phone networks in a failed attempt to crush the movement, so in one sense we can say that everything would have happened anyway. During this time, news and arrangements were spread by word of mouth, leaflets and landline phone calls – much more traditional means of communication.
However, social media was a key tool in raising awareness beforehand, most notably Wael Ghonim’s Facebook page “We are all Khaled Said” that highlighted police brutality, and in informing and connecting Egypt’s youth on a massive scale.
While illiteracy is high in Egypt, and not many people have internet access, it is the main areas of protest, Cairo and Alexandria, where people are most modernised, educated and connected, and therefore were able to organise online. For a revolution without real leadership, mass-based media was vital for spreading messages. State television was showing a bland array of documentaries while channels from outside of Egypt were securely off-air. However, the government was incapable of controlling the traffic on websites and so their barrier of censorship broke down.
On the other hand, the numbers of protesters didn’t really reach the millions until more than a week in, when ordinary, less tech-savvy Egyptians left their houses and began to discuss the events. In other words, the core of the protesters was already using social media, but the millions that joined them and tipped the balance relied on good old-fashioned word of mouth.
The real reason for the prominence of Facebook and Twitter in our understanding of the uprising was the style of media coverage, with 24 hour rolling news from the BBC and al-Jazeera. The journalists needed material to fill weeks of news and their movements were restricted on the streets of Egyptian cities by police harassment and arrests. Republishing witty, significant or emotional Tweets and Facebooks posts, such as those by “Sultanalqassemi” and “Draddee”, were easily accessible forms of first-hand information from the middle of the protests. At one stage, there were even Tweets celebrating being mentioned on al-Jazeera, in relation to a humorous trend entitled “why is Mubarak late?” before one of his speeches.
Libya’s story is different, far more bloody and chaotic, but just like Egypt, Gaddafi’s regime switched of the internet, mobile phone networks, and even landlines. Communication was almost impossible and terrifying rumours of violence were all that reached the outside world. The Libyan communications blackout was far more effective than Egyptian efforts, partly because Libyans are less well connected, and partly because foreign journalists were totally banned from the country. Even as chaos reigns, the regime threatens all journalists who have entered the `liberated’ zones with death.
Much of the communication took place over the internet and on mobile phones before the outbreak of violence so the groundwork was laid for mass demonstrations, which continued through the media blackout. The odd titbit of information that leaked out of Libya was analysed on news websites and blogs, but most of the `news’ over the first few days consisted of the reaction of human rights groups, Libyan political groups in exile and politicians. The media, Arab and Western, was trying to report on a situation without reliable information. But slowly, as foreign workers and Libyans trickled out of Libya, they passed on sticks and memory card of photos and information began to find its way to websites and the media, to be blogged about and re-tweeted, often by the same Egyptian bloggers.
The media attention helps keep up the international pressure, but Gaddafi pays no attention. The real events will take place in the conventional way, with machine guns and tribal alliances. Although American TV networks may crow that American social media caused these uprisings in hope of democracy, the true causes were economic. Rising food prices and unemployment were what pushed the average person onto the street all over the Middle East.
Other regimes in the region are trying to pre-empt revolts with democratic reforms, lifting emergency laws and reshuffling their cabinets. Syria for example, has removed its block on Facebook and Youtube. Before then, Syrian youths used a proxy to avoid government censorship and access sites like these. While it may seem like a positive move, the government can now track their activity with ease and Syrians have to be much more careful about what they post. In the future, security apparatus all over the world will pay much closer attention to what kids are saying on the web.
All this is a massive step on the road to citizen journalism, but we shouldn’t be fooled into thinking that social media sites created a digital revolution against an analogue regime. What these websites provided was a useful tool for expression, facilitating the power of ordinary people, from Morocco to Iran.

