Is De Gea’s time at Man United over?

By Zack Crawcour

Manchester United’s goalkeeper David De Gea has been criticised heavily throughout the season. The Red Devils finished the season with more clean sheets than any other team and as a result De Gea was awarded the prestigious Golden Glove. However, many fans and pundits argue that Man United’s exceptional defenders are the reason why De Gea won the award and that they should be commended instead.

So, why is De Gea being criticised? Well statistics alone show that he is severely underperforming compared to his Premier League counterparts. For starters, he has made the most goal-costing errors out of any Premier League keeper this season, level with Tottenham’s Hugo Lloris.

Passing and distribution has become a fundamental skill that keepers must master in this new era of football. Keepers who excel in passing, such as Ederson, start counterattacks as well as pressure opposition defenders. De Gea’s passing statistics are weak, with a measly 72% pass accuracy compared to his Liverpool counterpart Allison Becker’s 85.7%.

Manchester United manager Erik Ten Hag’s style of play focuses on transition football, building an attack utilising the entire team. A keeper who feels comfortable passing the ball around the back as well as having a high pass accuracy is crucial for Ten Hag’s philosophy and is required if the club wish to improve next season.

Therefore, Man United will likely delve into the transfer market to try and find a replacement for De Gea this Summer. But who are the potential candidates?

The most likely replacement for De Gea is David Raya. Raya already has an impressive resumé, starting for Brentford, consistently performing and overachieving in his last couple seasons, but also being selected for the Spanish national team — a team for which De Gea has not been selected recently. David Raya’s 2022/23 season statistics are astounding, ranking first in total saves and second in crosses caught.

A keeper who feels comfortable passing the ball around the back as well as having a high pass accuracy is crucial for Ten Hag’s philosophy

He is already an established shot-stopper, but what makes his game so unique is his ability to excel when it comes topassing. Brentford’s goalkeeping coach Steven Drench describes Raya as “like an extra outfield player” and this is apparent when it comes to his passing statistics.

Raya completed more long passes and overall passes than any Premier League keeper last season. He has evolved quickly to meet the demands of current football whilst at the same time excelling at the most important keeper trait: saving.

Therefore, he would be a fine addition to the Man United squad, adapting to their style of play, as well as bringing his own specialties to further improve their team. United’s other option is FC Porto’s starter: Diogo Costa.

This young and talented keeper has been gaining an impressive reputation at a staggering rate. At only 23, he was recently selected to start for the Portuguese national team. But why is he so sought after?

Costa is similar to Raya, excelling in shot-stopping, keeping 16 clean sheets in his 2022/23 campaign with Porto. Costa is also gifted when it comes to passing, showing his impressive distribution in the Champions League earlier this year. Costa fits the mould of the player that Ten Hag is looking for and although he is still young, he has already proven he has what it takes to compete at world level.

Ultimately, Man United need an upgrade this summer. The club will most likely prioritise the signing of Raya as he has already proven himself in the Premier League. However, Costa, and his vast potential, could be a great backup signing in case the Raya deal falls through.

Image: Saul Tevelez via Flickr