International student representatives adapt to new challenges

Breakdown of Durham students by nationality.
Breakdown of Durham students by nationality

By Justin Villamil

 

It is an undeniable fact that things are changing for international students at UK universities.

New controls on international student immigration proposed by the coalition government, rising numbers of international students present higher education institutions with a new set of challenge.

Meanwhile, traditional difficulties such as language barriers have not been fully tackled. With these challenges, Durham’s JCRs have had to adapt, both in administration and culture.

 

Traditional Challenges

Though there are many wide and political pressures exerted on international students, some of the most difficult ones to overcome are as simple as cultural and linguistic differences.

According to many international officers Palatinate spoke with, EU and North American students tend to adapt quickly to British culture and assimilate with relative ease.

Non EU-students, according to those interviewed, tend to have more trouble.

Colinette Wang is the international officer for John Snow College: “In general, the support given to International Students is plentiful because [for example] the University […] has a very helpful International office and English Language Focus groups, which students can easily book into.”

Wang is from Hong Kong, and says that she is therefore usually able to break down the language barrier.

This is especially helpful in John Snow where she says there are a higher proportion of Chinese students.

“Most of the students that arrive and have a problem tackling the English language are Chinese,” she told Palatinate.

“Therefore, I think I have succeeded in breaking the language barrier, having come from Hong Kong last year.”

The main danger, Colinette Wang told Palatinate, is that these students will form groups that speak only their native language and rarely venture out.

“Students who automatically talk in their home language in front of other students or university staff gradually come across as being rude, and therefore the reaction they get from others is usually exclusion,” Wang said.

Lizzie Reavley the international officer at St. John’s College is experiencing a similar problem.

“I think within John’s the international students are very much welcomed and feel part of college as a whole,” Reavley told Palatinate.

“However, often the Asian students can become more isolated due to a larger language barrier than those from other countries (including America and most European countries) – at least this was the case this year and last year.”

Reavley says that these students form the same groups Colinette talks about – isolated, and only speaking their first language.

While Reavley allows that this is a perfectly natural reaction upon coming to a new country, she says that for a university and college atmosphere, this is not ideal.

“This isolates other students from their conversations whilst simultaneously isolating themselves from the rest of college,” Reavley told Palatinate.

One of the solutions John’s uses to minimise this negative impact is to spread students out in their accommodations.

“John’s tries to ensure that the international students are spread out across college (in terms of rooms) to encourage students to socialise and get to know the home students as well,” Reavley said.

“This means that within John’s the international students aren’t necessarily obvious or isolated – no one is ignored or left alone.”

All data based on undergraduate statistics.
All data based on undergraduate statistics

Joe Deering of Hatfield agrees with the problem of the language barrier, but takes a different strategy to deal with the problems of isolation.

Deering believes that social events will bring people together more than anything, as all students no matter where they come from will generally come to college events. “Inevitably the language barrier is sometimes a divider, and naturally some tend to form groups based around this but at all college events they join in, so they don’t isolate themselves from college.”

No matter what the approach, however, none of the international officers Palatinate spoke to could say for sure what worked and what didn’t.

Overall, the feeling is that it the students who can’t engage with the rest of the student body are regrettable but inevitable.

“This is a small minority of students and the majority are very well integrated and inseparable from the home students,” Reavley told Palatinate.

 

New Challenges

Currently, some argue, in the UK, international students are facing increasing pressures and therefore require a support system from their colleges.

International students at Durham are facing changes in immigration policy proposed by the current government.

Two of the salient changes, as highlighted by the National Union of Students in a recent petition are charges for use of the NHS and fines for private landlords who don’t ensure that residents have the ability to reside in the UK.

For the NHS, the petition would include an estimated £200 charge for non-EEA international students to use NHS services.

“The further monitoring and regulation proposed by the Government is unnecessary, will cost more than it benefits and will unfairly target a group that contributes a phenomenal amount not just economically, but also to the strength of our education sector,” said the NUS in a recent statement.

Now more than ever, then, JCRs are put in the position of coping with both internal and external pressures on an increasingly internationally-represented student body.

In addition to these proposed changes, however, internationals already face new regulatory procedures upon graduation.

As Palatinate reported last year, the UK Border Agency (UKBA) has abolished the Tier 1 visa, which would have allowed students to stay in the UK for two years after graduation. Now, all international students must apply and keep a Tier 2 visa.

The Tier 2 visa is points-based, and in order to keep this visa, international workers must maintain a steady minimum £20,000 salary and comply with various field-specific regulations.

The question to be asked, then, is whether JCRs should create a more business-centred role to assist internationals looking to enter the workforce.

Catherine Ainsley of St. Cuthbert’s Society told Palatinate that the college is trying hard to take international opinion into account this year: “We are trying to improve this representation by having a international rep team of students to help plan events and give international students a bigger voice within the college.”

 

Representation Issues

The argument over representation is really an argument over whether international students should be treated just like any other student or if they should be treated as unique under the circumstances.

The majority of Durham’s colleges have some form of international officer, either as an executive role or as a non-exec officer.

Some see adding an exec officer role as a mechanism for further isolation.

Joe Deering, one of Hatfield’s international frep teams, believes that international students are generally fine with the current level of support.

“The feeling is that international students are treated just like home students, so the same support systems apply, and for those who have a problem related to their status as an international, the international rep team can handle it,” Deering told Palatinate. “There is a more than adequate welfare team to tend to their needs otherwise.”

Hatfield College has a team of four international freshman representatives that are then meant to exist in a supportive capacity for the rest of the year.

However, Deering admitted that increased international numbers this year have exerted pressure on Hatfield.

“With the increased number of international students my college needs to establish a larger number of reps for them and create more defined roles for the international reps which extend past fresher’s [week],” Deering told Palatinate.

Deering added that Hatfield is currently in the process of re-developing the role of the international team. “Internationals have other needs and problems that can arise, and having a defined role to take care of those issues (banking, visas etc.) is paramount to a successful college environment.”

Other colleges take the opposite approach.

New Area Graph
All data based on undergraduate statistics.

Hilde and Bede has the most international representation of all Durham’s colleges.

Lina Bøe, the international officer sits on the executive committee but also has three more international representatives that work beneath her.

Bøe is adamant that every college should adopt such a role.

I definitely think all colleges need reps to represent international students as there are more things to consider for us that come from abroad,” Bøe told Palatinate.

As to whether the role in college should be an exec or non-exec position, Bøe said that though she recognises variation between colleges, in the case of Hilde and Bede it should be an exec position.

“Being a big college like Hild Bede I think it is necessary that at least one rep is on the exec,” she told Palatinate. “The purpose not only being better communication with the college and the student body and representation, but to work against the ‘us and them’ mentality that is sometimes found in Durham.”

Josephine Butler College is currently considering adding an executive position for international representative. Butler already has two international representatives, and has created an ‘international committee’ to bridge the gap between home and international students in the college. Butler’s JCR President, William Kendall, told Palatinate that nothing has officially been decided, but that “a recent focus group suggested this may be useful.”

According to Kendall, the outcome of this proposal is still up in the air, but will be discussed further in upcoming Butler exec and JCR meetings.

While Butler’s discussion about additional representation for international students is commendable, there is some question as to whether it is needed, as international students seem to be well integrated into the college already.

Kendall described this integration as stemming from an inclusive attitude. He told Palatinate that the approach of Butler’s current international representatives, Nicolas Restrepo and Dharrnesha Inbah-Rajah, is to “project Butler’s cultural diversity … throughout the college.”

Kendall further stated that instead of problematizing international students, Butler instead celebrates diversity: “Events like World Cinema nights, Global Voices current affairs debates, trips to hear speakers, February’s One World Week, [and the] Chinese New Year Formal are all excellent examples.”

But Josephine Butler isn’t the only college considering the contentious issue. Olivia Ryan, the St. Aidan’s College Vice-President told Palatinate that Aidan’s already has an international welfare representative role.

“We don’t have an international Exec member,” Ryan told Palatinate. “But we are considering adding another international rep role onto another one of our committees, which is still under debate and will hopefully be passed as a motion at our next JCR meeting.”

However, Ryan went on to state that the nature of Aidan’s is such that a committee position would be directly responsible to the committee chair, and therefore preferable to a ‘sub-exec’ position.

“I think the internationals could use a bit more representation and integration at Aidan’s,” Ryan told Palatinate.

Ryan, who is originally from the United States, says she had no trouble herself.

“It wasn’t so hard to feel at home because English is my first language, but I have a lot of friends who had a lot more trouble,” Ryan said.

St. John’s College faces a similar problem of carrying support for internationals throughout the year. “During freshers’ and international welcome week there is plenty of support for students within John’s as the international reps are very much present,” Lizzie Reavley, John’s International Officer, told Palatinate. “Throughout the rest of the year we are trying to be present and the college support networks (such as tutors and welfare) which are set up for all students are always there.”

Graphs by: Justin Villamil