Infantino refugee comments expose FIFA ignorance and greed

By Orlando Bell

“We need to give opportunities and we need to give dignity […] not by giving charity, but by allowing the rest of the world to participate. We need to give hope to Africans so they don’t need to cross the Mediterranean in order to find, maybe, a better life, but more probably death in the sea.”

These are the extraordinary words of FIFA President Gianni Infantino when pitching a biennial World Cup. Within them the weight of institutionally-embedded prejudice comes to bear. Even from an organisation that has shown itself unfit for purpose on such a number of occasions, the level of ignorance and insensitivity displayed by Infantino is depressing.

The response from Human Rights Watch is almost comical given its obvious absurdity. Media Director Andrew Stroehlein tweeted: “my colleagues at Human Rights Watch interview refugees around the world pretty much every day […] They never mention the timing of World Cup tournaments.”

Mr. Stroehlein is being polite. Infantino’s comments reflect gross misunderstandings of African history and of migrants. Perhaps the obvious place to start is the reductionism of viewing Africa in such homogenising terms. In addition to the vastly different economies, environments, political configurations, and distances that differentiate the continent – the 7600 kilometres that separate Tunis (Tunisia) from Cape Town (SA) is approximately the same distance as between Brussels and Beijing – such generalised descriptions of Africa have a deeply problematic history.

Terms such as ‘The Dark Continent’, coined by nineteenth century explorer Henry Morton Stanley, popularised an image of the continent as a single historical unit – unified by a lack of European knowledge, inaccessibility, and danger. This image was a myth from its inception, an arbitrary unification determined by normative European perceptions. Yet its underlying preconceptions of Africa as a single unit, foreign to European familiarity, somewhat backward and in need of change through outside interaction, problematically remain in ignorant discourse.

As Infantino speaks to his audience at the Council of Europe about the “dignity” of a continent being raised by a sports tournament, and when “charity” is the only alternative he considers, history and structural power make his ignorance and prejudice inexcusable.

The migrant crisis has been normalised to the point of being desensitised

The fact that his assumption onmigration went unchallenged at the Council of Europe is similarly concerning. The mid 2010s saw a wave of largely right-wing anti- imimgration politics break across the European continent. As Brexit, Marine le Pen, and the Syrian refu- gee crisis broadly converged, the European discourse on refugees and migrants became dominated by debates over immigraiton’s im- pact on host nations and the nature of economic migrants versus ‘true’ asylum seekers. Legitimate debates about the impacts of economic migration, retaining salience from the large-scale eastern European migration of the Blair years, became falsely entangled with the plight of asylum seekers.

The brutal reality of the desperation behind those crossing the Mediterranean became lost in this discourse, and continues to be lost today. The migrant crisis has been normalised to the point of being desensitised. To cross the Mediterranean uproots families, involves leaving behind communities and connections, and facing extreme danger on the road and the sea.

It is rarely, if ever, an act of truly free choice, but rather one of desperation. Those that face these challenges, for the future of their own lives and for that of their families, do so with more ‘dignity’ than Infantino of FIFA have ever possessed. Infantino’s core assumption as to the benefits of a biennial World Cup hinge on the additional £3.3 billion pounds the tournament would generate. This, it is argued, would be reinvested into burgeon- ing football nations, creating investment and opportunities and a lasting socio-economic impact.

In the context of nearly a century of failed ‘development’ schemes imposed on Africa by outside organisations, and in the context of the true complexity that leads
to migrant crises in these regions, Infantino’s notion that this would truly make a socioeconomic difference is laughable.

FIFA wants this revenue for its own ends – to compete with UEFA and to promote its own brand. The ‘dignity’ of Africans – whatever that may mean – is not the priority of the organisation. Infantino’s language, false pretence, and ignorance must be roundly condemned.

Image: Présidence de la République du Bénin via flickr