In Wales, Parents Will No Longer be Able to Pull Their Children Out of Religious and Sex Education

By Meera Navlakha

On 21st January, the Welsh government announced that religious and sex education will now be compulsory. Parents will no longer have the means to withdraw their children from these classes. This will be tested in a trial run in 2021 but will become statutory in 2022. 

Wales is set to be the first place in the UK to implement the arrangement. Up until now, parents in the area have been granted the right to use the ‘opt-out’ rule. 

According to the BBC, Education Minister Kirsty Williams said black, Asian, and minority ethnic (BAME) and other faith groups will be integrated into the process of developing the curriculum. This promises the treatment of a ‘sensitive matter’ with the due diligence given to a range of communities. Williams acknowledged that the subjects will have to be handled carefully.

The new curriculum will be renamed Religion, Values, and Ethics. 

Gabrielle Raw-Rees, a third-year from Grey College, recalls her experience with RE during her education at Wales. At a small Welsh primary school, her religious studies teacher would provide lessons once or twice a month. She doesn’t remember these classes being particularly intense.

A legal expert, warned that the policy could be a breach of human rights that parents could take legal action against.

‘It was quite relaxed overall but I do remember that any religious education I got was skewed quite a lot towards Christianity and Islam,’ she notes.

‘At the time, I didn’t consider it intense but I didn’t know any better. The staff definitely assumed we were all religious. There weren’t people of any other faith, they were either Christian or atheist,’ said Raw-Rees who identifies as an atheist herself. ‘I’m sure there were students who felt uncomfortable at times, but there weren’t any complaints or opt-outs that I knew of.’

HIV and sexual health advocates have received the news positively, with many suggesting that this will improve the collective understanding of sex, relationships, and sexuality. The charity, Terrence Higgins Trust, tweeted that this is ‘great news for young people in Wales.’

Debbie Laycock, the head of policy at the Terrence Higgins Trust, told The Guardian, ‘Until now far too many young people have learned about sex through whispers in the playground. This decision by the Welsh government will go some way to fixing this.

When it comes to religious education, those who uphold that compulsory classes are beneficial for students have similar beliefs. Most suggest that this is the best route for young people to learn about all faiths, rather than having knowledge solely concerning their own views.

‘Until now far too many young people have learned about sex through whispers in the playground.’

However, religious and secular groups have their respective concerns. Humanists UK, which advocates for secularism, said that the problem with compulsory religious education (RE) is that ‘schools will still be able to teach the subject from a faith-based perspective.’ According to a tweet from the organisation, this is a notable concern when it comes to faith schools, more so than community schools. A representative for the group said that RE can lead to ‘young people being indoctrinated against their or their parents’ wishes.’

On 8th February, the BBC reported that the Welsh government is in danger of being taken to court over this decision. Sir Malcolm Evans, a legal expert, warned that the policy could be a breach of human rights that parents could take legal action against. 

According to the Durham Law Review,  Article 8 of the Human Rights Act 1998 revolves around the ‘right to respect private and family life, his home and his correspondence,’ while Article 9 pertains to the ‘freedom of thought, conscience, and religion.’ The Welsh government may find these aspects difficult to combat should be they taken to court. Sir Malcolm suggests that this would only occur if the curriculum is not wholly inclusive or holistic.

‘In my view having an opt-out is very much a safety valve,’ he told the BBC. 

Photo by Carolyn V via Unsplash.