In the Crick of it: regret, pressure and evolution in the world of political journalism

By Ella Catherall 

In 2005, a common joke in journalism was that the five most terrifying words in the political lexicon are “Michael Crick is in reception.”

My experience, thankfully, was rather different, and as he begins to reminisce on his time as Oxford Union President, I breathe a sigh of relief that I’m the one asking the questions today.

“I had a whale of a time”, he recalls. The list of speakers he hosted who went on to big things is long and impressive, but one name sticks out from the rest. “Theresa May’s husband, Philip, was President of the Union the term before me, and I knew him a bit better than Theresa.”

[blockquote author=”” pull=”normal”]“She was quite difficult to get to know, was Theresa”[/blockquote]

The picture he paints of our Prime Minister is one quite different from the May we recognise today. Crick reckons she was ‘a better speaker than she is now”, and claims that when she is relaxed, she can be ‘”very very funny.” I guess we’ll have to take his word on that one.

[blockquote author=”” pull=”normal”]“She was quite difficult to get to know, was Theresa”[/blockquote]

Despite the hard time politicians get from Crick nowadays, it could have been him getting a grilling of that kind. “My ambition was at that stage to go into politics, but in those days it was much more difficult.”

A lack of opportunities steered Crick into journalism instead, and he quickly decided he “liked it too much” to quit.

Crick admits he “occasionally” regrets not pursuing political rank when he sees contemporaries line the front benches, but recognises the immense pressures MPs have to deal with. Although they may have more power, he claims, “I’m sure I’ll have more fun.”

Crick has seen a lot change since the start of his broadcasting career in the 1980s.

“When I started in television there were only 3 channels: BBC1, BBC2 and ITV”, he recalls, and while he recognises that an increase in competition between stations is healthy, he claims there are “severe drawbacks” to the pluralism of today’s media.

With radio, television and newspapers merging online and losing individual influence, Crick believes serious journalism is “in decline”, and this can have grave consequences for what he sees as the purpose of journalism – holding powerful people to account.

[blockquote author=”” pull=”normal”]“Essentially our job is to hold powerfully people to account”[/blockquote]

“I suspect some people in power feel a little more relaxed and comfortable than they did ten or twenty years ago”, he explains.

Crick believes politicians don’t worry about journalists the same way they did years ago; they don’t have the same fear that whatever they do wrong will end up in the press.

“It’s our job to keep them on their toes”, he explains, and while he admits journalists may only uncover “one percent of the world’s wrongdoing”, he emphasises that such thinking misses the point. “They’ve got to be worried about the possibility we might expose their wrongdoing.”

Despite this, Crick insists we “needn’t worry” about the future of journalism anytime soon, and although it “ain’t gonna be the world of yesterday”, he believes political journalism is “hugely stronger” than it used to be.

“When I first became a journalist in the eighties, the lobby were much more deferential towards politicians”, he explains, but now believes journalists are much more “challenging” towards people at the top.

[blockquote author=”” pull=”normal”]“I love Twitter, it’s given me a new lease of life”[/blockquote]

Just ten years ago, Blair and Brown used to give monthly press conferences, but “May and Corbyn never do that.”

Even though he admits they are now “terrified of scrutiny”, when asked whether this is necessary, he couldn’t be clearer: “Yes! The people in power should be asked tough questions at regular intervals”, he explains.

Luckily it doesn’t seem Michael will be stopping anytime soon, and he doesn’t appear to be trailing contemporaries in the online world either.

“I love Twitter, it’s given me a new lease of life”, he claims. As well as using it for “little thoughts, little quirks”, it has journalistic purposes too, and allows Crick to put out things quickly that “can’t wait till 7 o’clock.”

It can be “terribly dangerous” he admits, however, and confesses a tweet or two might have got him into trouble in the past.

[blockquote author=”” pull=”normal”]“I decided I wasn’t going to vote, because it doesn’t feel right”[/blockquote]

Although he now takes care to remain unbiased on social media platforms, Crick is a “great believer” in the idea that broadcasting rules on objectivity should apply to journalists on Twitter too.

As lines between online and television journalism become increasingly blurred, a new set of rules must be formed to navigate this new realm, and Crick believes neutrality is the key to staying sane in political broadcasting.

This neutrality extends to his personal life too, and Crick is quick to stress that he has no party biases when asked about politics- in fact, he doesn’t even vote. While this may seem surprising for someone so politically-minded, he insists he has “fewer and fewer views” as his career goes on.

Photograph: Martin Deutsch via Flickr