In defence of ‘The Hobbit’: a cautionary tale in studio gluttony

By Kaeah Sen

In 2004, Peter Jackson made history at the Academy Awards. The third instalment of his Lord of the Rings (LOTR) franchise, The Lord of the Rings: The Return of the King, won all eleven of its nominations, achieving tied first place for the most Oscars ever won by a single film. Less than a decade later, it was announced that The Hobbit, Tolkien’s beloved precursor to LOTR, would be adapted for the big screen. Fans all over the world rejoiced at the chance to see Middle Earth again, and all seemed right with the world.

Cut to: 2014, following the release of the final film. Disappointment prevailed. The Hobbit films had failed to live up to the expectations of the original trilogy; walking away with zero Oscars, earning a mediocre profit, and leaving Tolkien fans wholly unsatisfied.

December 2022 saw the ten year anniversary of The Hobbit: An Unexpected Journey, and to commemorate one of my (controversial) all-time favourite films, I want to explore the trilogy’s complex production, and to give a few reasons as to why perhaps the films aren’t all that bad.

First, a plot summary: the peace-loving hobbit Bilbo Baggins joins thirteen dwarves as they set out to reclaim their lost Kingdom and the gold within it from the dragon Smaug. Tolkien’s novel is a humble tale of adventure, and a reminder that courage and kindness are worth more than all the gold in the world. It seems like a winning storyline. So why did the films, which were slated to be rousing successes, end up firmly between 50-70% reviews on Rotten Tomatoes? From a last-minute change of directors to studio interference, investigation into the films’ production suggests that The Hobbit’s failure was destined from the start.

There were ultimately several production companies who all were entitled to a slice of the profit pie. The result – it was paramount the films made as much money as possible

The LOTR films were produced by Metro Goldwyn Mayer, who had the rights to Tolkien’s novels. But for The Hobbit, MGM had to make a deal with Warner Bros. to finance the films, due to their significant debt. Because of various other rights issues, there were ultimately several production companies who all were entitled to a slice of the profit pie. The result – it was paramount the films made as much money as possible.

In 2008, it was officially announced that award-winning director Guillermo del Toro would make The Hobbit into two two-hour films. But in early 2010, with little explanation, it was announced that Peter Jackson would be taking over, with del Toro citing “ongoing delays” and “mounting pressures” as reasons for departure.

Jackson was thus thrown into directing without time to prepare. This clearly spelled out failure, as films of this scope require extensive pre-production – LOTR had almost four years. The production was hectic from the start, with Jackson later stating he “made it up as [he] went along”. To add to the chaos, mere months before the release of the first film, an announcement revealed there would now be an additional third film. Jackson was suddenly thrust into rewrites, reshoots, and the unimaginable challenge of stretching one novel into three separate, cohesive storylines.

This messy production serves as an explanation for the films’ quality. Despite Warner Bros.’ desire to create great movies, they fell into all the conventions of mediocre Hollywood franchises.

Studio-related blunders aside, there are actually plenty of moments of sheer magic in these films, moments which allow them to rise, at times, to the greatness of the original trilogy.

Tolkien wrote The Hobbit for children, and these films undoubtedly capture the light-heartedness of the novel. Thirteen dwarves make for some great comedic moments, but the best is Martin Freeman’s performance, with his effortless charm and sensibility making him the perfect Bilbo.

The films serve as a meta-cautionary tale for what happens when a Hollywood studio gets greedy

The film’s artisanal work is incredible, with Jackson’s penchant for precision conveyed through magnificent sets, props, and costumes. The cinematography is equally noteworthy, with the awe-inspiring vistas of New Zealand (now synonymous with Middle Earth) captured through breath-taking wide shots. All of this is set to Howard Shore’s resplendent score. After winning three Oscars for LOTR, Shore returned with the themes that made the original trilogy so memorable, as well as new ones which encompass Bilbo’s epic journey.

These elements all speak to Jackson’s filmmaking prowess – the fact that he was able to put together three entertaining and (somewhat) cohesive films despite the challenges presented by the studios is a testament to his directing capabilities.

For all their flaws, The Hobbit films encapsulate Tolkien’s thematic ideas in a way only Peter Jackson could. The production drama ultimately serves as a meta-cautionary tale for what happens when a Hollywood studio gets greedy, and cares more about profit than the actual story they are telling.

And with that, a line from the film: “If more people valued home above gold, the world would be a merrier place”.

Image: Charles Lebegue via Unsplash